Elektrine lite

← Feed

@soratoyuki@piefed.zip

2026-10-16 18:29 UTC

Genuine question. I’m not a developer, I didn’t study computer science, and I’m a pretty basic Fedora user. But why does everyone harp on Linus Torvald’s opinions like they’re handed down from heaven? Windows still dominates the market, but no one cares what Bill Gates says. I love A Song of Ice and Fire but I wouldn’t take writing tips from George R. R. Martin. Richard Stallman’s opinions on GNU/Linux are memed endlessly. Linus is literally just a dude.

Replies (9)

  • @Solumbran@lemmy.world 2026-10-16 18:31

    Because people’s love of cults of personality is endless. Add on top of that the “AI” cult that saw this as an amazing recruitment opportunity, and you get a nice combo. That’s basically the computer science equivalent of having a famous actor advertise a sect.

    Open ##5066555

  • @digdilem@lemmy.ml 2026-10-16 18:33

    Windows still dominates the market, What market? Desktops? Sure. Servers? Definitely not. Supercomputers? Like, none of them.

    Open ##5066636

  • Bill Gates doesn’t work on Windows anymore and hasn’t got years. George R R Martin doesn’t publish books anymore and hasn’t forgotten years. Richard Stallman is…a weird little guy. Whether you like it or not Linus is still the Linux guy.

    Open ##5066808

  • @mushroommunk@lemmy.today 2026-10-16 18:48

    As someone who did study computer science and has worked in embedded processor space (so one of the people who’s written assembly by hand he’s talking about). I’ve never understood it either. People take his word as law blindly and it’s never made sense to me. Yes he has skill, but so do hundreds of others. Yes he’s opinionated, that’s certainly not a reason to hero worship him. For ten+ years people have been pointing out he’s basically a single point of failure for Linux and begging for a succession plan and he’s been too stuck up his own ass to accept that he isn’t the only one who cares about all this. This has lead to some extreme cult following behind him for some reason.

    Open ##5066859

  • @corsicanguppy@lemmy.ca 2026-10-16 18:55

    Linux is his. He gets to make the rules. We get to decide whether to bail. I don’t understand confusion or entitlement over this.

    Open ##5067001

  • @wesker@lemmy.sdf.org 2026-10-16 19:12

    I’m not a developer, I didn’t study computer science It’s okay, none of the most hardline anti-AI folks on here are, but they certainly like to pretend they know the tools and the industry.

    Open ##5067828

  • @uszo165@futurology.today 2026-10-16 19:57

    Because he’s not some guy on the internet saying his opinion, he is maintaining the most relevant Free Software kernel. So if he goes nuts, there is great potential for great disaster. I don’t think there are Linux distributions that use forks of the Linux kernel. (What notable forks are there anyway?) At the moment, they all depend on the original Linux kernel. There is currently no alternative. It would take a lot of disruption and a tremendous effort to establish and switch to a fork of the Linux kernel that is free of Linus’ influence. Today, I’d say jokingly I will switch to FreeDOS. But if this sloppification goes on, I guess I will have to.

    Open ##5068313

  • @Not_mikey@lemmy.dbzer0.com 2026-10-16 23:46

    Because he still the main maintainer and a developer on a piece of software core to a lot of modern computing. If he is wrong on this it could ruin the credibility and reliability of Linux and cause a fork that could tear the community and ecosystem apart. If he’s right he’s proved that AI can make maintainable, reliable core infrastructure code and the field will change to reflect that. Can’t tell your boss AI sucks and is unreliable and I won’t use it if AI code is working well at the base of modern computer software.

    Open ##5071876

  • @VAK@lemmy.world 2026-10-17 01:22

    Why wouldn’t you take writing tips from GRRM?

    Open ##5072915