@ianbetteridge@social.vivaldi.net
2026-04-11 20:51 UTC
@hopeless @seb321 Hmmm, ok, it's more nuanced than this. We have roughly 225 warheads, but, since the end of production of the WE177 freefall bomb, we're entirely dependent on US-sourced missiles to deliver them. Without US servicing they wouldn't be operational for long.
France, meanwhile, has an entirely independent system: warheads, M51 SLBMs, ASMP-A cruise missiles.
Developing our own missile capability or working with France to replace Trident would take anything from 5-20 years of work, and an enormous amount of money. Effectively, the US could end our independent deterrant at any time if it chose to.
Taking into account the cost of Trident, and the investment required into Dreadnaught, we would save around £5bn a year. That money could go into drone warfare, air defence, and munitions stockpiles, which are exactly the areas that have been cut so we can afford nukes.
You cannot deter nuclear blackmail with conventional forces. But we are also making a huge investment in a capability that we can never use, at the cost of conventional forces which combat the threats we actually face. Maintaining a nuclear threat while cutting conventional forces is probably the worst option, and it's the one we have pursued, in part, because dropping nukes has been seen as off the table.
Replies (1)
-
@seb321@toot.community 2026-04-12 07:03
@ianbetteridge @hopeless Thanks, you explain this much better than I can. The bottom line is that nuclear weapons are useless as a deterrent against rogue dictators who are really the only ones who are likely to use them against us. Having any weapons linked to the US makes us a target for reasons of (see above) we have no control over. There are no realistic scenarios where nuclear weapons make us safer rather than less safe.