2026-11-14 11:19 UTC
My point was that it’s not EDK2 instead of GRUB at the same layer: EDK2 is the UEFI layer, and GRUB still runs fine on top of it as an EFI binary from your ESP. All the things you listed keep working that way: LUKS, RAID, password protection, even memtest via the efi/ insert mechanism. What you lose is only having GRUB directly in CBFS without an ESP.
What you gain with EDK2: Windows boots at all, TPM 2.0 works (the SeaBIOS issues that got it disabled are gone), and option ROMs for external GPUs.
Replies (1)
-
@ExtremeUnicorn@feddit.org 2026-11-14 12:24
Hmm. Having EDK2 in flash defeats the purpose of having a customized secure GRUB config, because you can just escape EDK2 to boot whatever you want. Do you happen to know if EDK2 can be configured to only load a specific executable and prevent or password protect external boot sources? Loading Windows… sigh. What target group that is interested in custom BIOS firmware seriously wants to ever boot Windows? I guess there are very few legitimate usecases, but FreeDOS exists. Loading OpROMs is a capability of coreboot, no need for SeaBIOS/vgabios or EDK2 just for that. TPM2 support is also part of coreboot? Here I am unsure.