Elektrine lite

← Feed

@froge@social.glitched.systems

2025-03-25 13:28 UTC

@kkarhan@infosec.space @fj@mastodon.social that's fine, I actually really like deltachat and a few others, but none of them pretend to match the same level of security as Signal because they're not actually the same level of security/privacy/confidentiality in the real world, I don't really trust signal self hosting their servers either but that doesn't mean these alternatives match the same level of privacy and security on a technical level for example the encryption used by Deltachat openly has flaws and doesn't support perfect forward secrecy in the cryptography, this is on purpose, they mention it several times in the documentation, because their goal is to be compatible with existing email systems and that requires protocol constraints and trade offs Fact is deltachat (and many others on this list) are not as cryptographically secure as signal, and they're not trying to be, and that's fine as long as you understand many of these tools make tradeoffs in their privacy/security in unique ways for their use cases still doesn't mean any of them will provide the same level of secure and private service that signal does, even if they are more decentralized and cheaper/easier sometimes for some people

Replies (1)

  • @brahms@chaos.social 2025-03-25 14:26

    @froge @kkarhan @fj decentralization is something you generally dont want, unless you properly solve it at the protocol level. Thats why matrix sucks and will always be inferior to a centralized solution like signal (unless fixed at protocol level, which most likely wont happen). and yeah, most "competitors" arent really ones, if they think PFS is optional ...

    Open ##1342322