Elektrine lite

← Feed

@spicystraw@lemmy.world

2026-11-14 10:54 UTC

Ok so my issue with this post isn’t “trans women are women”, I agree with that, and it’s not really the argument anyway. It’s the words “biological” and “born”. Nobody’s born a woman. You’re born with a sex, and sometimes that’s not even clear-cut. “Woman” is a grown-up category, not something you come out of the womb with. Same with “biological sex.” It’s not one thing. Chromosomes, gametes, gonads, what organs you’ve got, what hormones are running through you, those don’t always point the same direction in the same person. That’s what the term covers, clinically. This is important. Trans woman on estrogen? Higher clot risk. Still got a prostate? Still needs checking. Creatinine ranges, QT intervals, drug doses, how trauma patients clot, all split by sex in the scientific literature. Trans women are women. But the medical chart should say organ inventory, hormones, and surgical history, not six silly lines of affirmation. That’s not a dig at anyone. It’s important to avoid missing something at 3am in an ED.

Replies (4)

  • I don’t necessarily have problems with the veracity of the claims you’re making, but I do have two questions: Are you a doctor, and do you have a trans patient? If not, why is this so important to you?

    Open ##5534998

  • @SavarosaCraft@lemmy.world 2026-11-15 00:15

    I would also leave out the biology part of the list. Because that is just going to cause problems. You can be whatever you want to be and you should be respected as such. But what hardware are you operating on is kinda important in a medical sense. There is a reason why a doctor first question is: Are you pregnant? Is there a chance of pregnancy? This is an undeniable fact - they ask this question even if you went through a total removal of your insides. Biological parts do need different upkeep.

    Open ##5537794

  • doctors should be actually pragmatic and give regard to the relevant specifics rather than our stupid abstractions that miss important edge cases doing otherwise is malpractice because it means they do a worse job than they easily could JUST BY NOT APPLYING THESE PRESUMPTIONS for example disease more dangerous if theres a uterus for it to infect? then ask “do you have a uterus” not “are you a woman” its easy

    Open ##5538168

  • @Nouvellalia@lemmy.world 2026-11-15 07:04

    Is this a medical chart? Is it telling doctors how to do their job? Your “problem with this post” is something you made up completely to have a thin excuse to point out that trans women are “other”. Weird that you felt the need to find some way some how to other trans women. Wait, not weird. Telling. “Six silly lines of affirmation”. It’s honestly impressive how much you bothered to larp scientist just to sneak in your bullshit.

    Open ##5539001