Elektrine lite

← Feed

@antoinechambertloir@mathstodon.xyz

2026-09-10 19:51 UTC

#Math #AI 16/n I needed several toots to tell this story of the Jacobian conjecture that ran from July 19th to September 4th, but the story doesn't stop here! One month later, Alpöge published a counterexample to another conjecture, and also a longer text building a complex structure on the 6-dimensional sphere. I have not much to say about them. The first one is presented on the form of a tweet, while the second one takes the form of a long paper, that starts with something that looks like some genuine mathematical insight, but the text lacks a proper introduction that would explain where the idea comes from, whether there had been earlier attempts in a similar vein, etc. On August 1st, another company, Open AI released a paper “Ten advances in mathematics and theoretical computer science” giving a proof of 10 new results in several areas of mathematics. Most of them seem to be optimization of existing work, but some look genuinely new. Still, the writing is often inadequate, with a much too strong emphasis being put on the proven results.

Replies (2)

  • #Math #AI 17/n For example, the existence of non-sofic groups is presented as “addressing a central open question in group theory”, while it is certainly not central. Moreover, the solution to this question seems to have benefited from AI-work by mathematician Andreas Thom (on this network) who had used Chat-GPT (OpenAI's LLM) to investigate that question. The answers he gets are really puzzling, and I can join him on one point, “can we trust OpenAI with unpublished mathematics”? Indeed, if it happens that private discussions on Chat-GPT help train the model, people using this technology would basically have all OpenAI mathematicians spying what they do behind their back. Of course, OpenAI says that no such thing happens, but how can we know? https://mathstodon.xyz/@andreasthom/117240535270608201

    Open ##5153666

  • @michaelmaex@mastodon.online 2026-09-10 21:07

    @antoinechambertloir@mathstodon.xyz It is almost tautological that if a mathematical work is in the training data, the LLM will reproduce it. The entire point is to imitate the training data. Worse is that it happens by nature without attribution. After all, if the training data claims to invent a new technique so will the output. This is fundamentally different to a text that is in the context, where the LLM is at least “aware” it is using something else, and it did not “reason” itself to that point.

    Open ##5153706