Elektrine lite

← Feed

@homesweethomeMrL@lemmy.world

2026-11-06 16:45 UTC

Democrats Need to Talk About Supreme Court Expansion Now Without control of the White House, there is of course only so much Democrats can do with their newfound power. And in the context of the myriad horrors of the first half of President Donald Trump’s second term, talking about what the party “should” do next is roughly analogous to deciding which out-of-control forest fire to fight first: There is not enough water, there are lots of worthy candidates, and all of them are getting worse.  One thing must be true, though: Whatever issues Democratic lawmakers choose to focus on—and, as the 2028 ideas primary gets underway, whatever ambitious ideas Democratic presidential hopefuls choose to support—the party must also have a plan for taking on the Supreme Court, which remains an existential threat to anything Democrats might hope to accomplish. Even if the party is fortunate enough to win a trifecta—the House, the Senate, and the White House—in 2028, things like a Green New Deal and Medicare for All and a new Voting Rights Act do not stand a chance before this six-justice conservative supermajority. Regrettably, what I wrote in 2020 is just as true today: If Congress passes any one of these proposals into law, the only real question is which justice ends up writing the opinion that kills it.

Replies (12)

  • @SabinStargem@lemmy.today 2026-11-07 02:31

    We don’t need just more justices. We need age and term limits. Being allowed to feather their nests with bribes forever has clearly corrupted many of the justices on the bench.

    Open ##5533282

  • @godsammitdam@lemmy.zip 2026-11-07 04:49

    Better yet, this. Have Congress pen a law that says “the supreme court can’t constitutionally overturn this.” When they challenge it, they’d have to cite where in the constitution they are provided such power. And that doesn’t exist. Judicial supremacy is removed.

    Open ##5534736

  • @BigMacHole@thelemmy.club 2026-11-07 04:56

    Voters turning MISSISSIPPI BLUE is NOT a Sign that we should do Something EXTREME like This! INSTEAD Voters PROBABLY want to See us HELP Trump with His Agenda! -Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer!

    Open ##5534916

  • @opus86@lemmy.today 2026-11-07 05:09

    The Supreme Court has been proven that it can be corrupted. It needs to be rebuilt so that can’t happen again.

    Open ##5535124

  • @BarneyPiccolo@lemmy.today 2026-11-07 00:44

    I used to believe that we needed expand SCOTUS to 13, but I no longer believe that. Now I believe that we should expand SCOTUS to 29 seats, with rolling term limits, so every president gets to appoint a few. The number of seats shouldn’t be so low that one bad faith president can negatively affect governmental policy for the next 50 years.

    Open ##5535169

  • @electric_nan@lemmy.ml 2026-11-07 02:32

    Very hard to imagine. Most Democrats genuinely believe that the system can be fixed by sheer force of ‘civility’. Packing the court is too far outside of ‘the norm’.

    Open ##5535211

  • @bagsy@lemmy.world 2026-11-07 02:39

    I think 9 judges is probably fine, but they should be term limited to 18 years, and we replace one judge every 2 years. Every president would get to seat a minimum of 2 judges. It would limit all the politicking around placing a judge, it would also eliminate the game of placing a young idealist that can server for 50 years.

    Open ##5535430

  • @crystalmerchant@lemmy.world 2026-11-07 05:35

    Betcha 10 bucks they don’t

    Open ##5535727

  • @modestmeme@lemmy.world 2026-11-06 17:04

    Nah. It’s mucking too much with the Constitution and undoubtedly will be used against the country the very minute Republicans regain Congressional majority. That and DC statehood (DC is separate for a reason) are just dumb ideas. Focus our efforts on overturning Citizens United and reforming the manner in which campaign finances work. And absolutely prosecute every last bit of corruption and profiteering done by any politician. Make Congress a means of public service far and above any means of making money.

    Open ##5536054

  • @anarchy79@lemmy.world 2026-11-07 05:52

    Here’s another thing that needs to be addressed: In 1789 each house representative represented roughly 5000 voters. Each senator represented roughly 14000 voters. In 2026 each house representative represents roughly 600,000 voters. Each senator represents roughly 2.5 million voters.

    Open ##5536231

  • @Objection@lemmy.ml 2026-11-07 06:08

    While I agree in principle with expanding the court and breaking its power, I don’t think the time is right for seriously proposing it. The midterms were more a rejection of Trump than an endorsement of a Democratic agenda. The upset, red-state victories were about ending the war and lowering gas prices, not about fundamentally transforming the balance of power in the state. The senators in those states will not support those measures (if they want to have a chance at reelection), so even with a trifecta it’s unlikely to go through. In the meantime, the Democrats will appear power-hungry and the right will have plenty of material to fear-monger, and there’s also legitimate concerns about the right taking power and doing the same thing. The best way to approach major judicial reform would be to put it directly in the hands of the people, through something like a national referendum. There isn’t really a process for national level referendums here in the States, but even some kind of non-binding resolution could better assess the popular will and provide a clearer mandate. Currently, what we have are polls, which show a roughly even split for and against, with clearer support for term limits. So enact term limits, say you don’t think it goes far enough, but promise that you won’t go further without a clear mandate from the people.

    Open ##5536697

  • The SC would just rule it unconstitutional and end of story. Why are we talking about this? Even FDR couldn’t do it. en.wikipedia.org/…/Judicial_Procedures_Reform_Bil… What we do have a mechanism to do is impeach Justices and plenty of cause to do so.

    Open ##5537270