← Feed
This is the fallacy. It is not simply “My money/time” -> “Unique thing”. The entire technological base of human civilizatio made it possible for you to make that thing. Most of the costs were bore by society. Yet you would now wish to privitize the profits and deny society access to that way to do things without your permission.
Take open heart surgery for example. There is very clearly a right way to do it. Perhaps a few good ways to do it too. But 1 way is the BEST way. Imagine if only 1 surgeon owned the patent to that best way. Other surgeons have to figure out their own way. Even if they figure out the same way as him independently he did it first so they can’t use it. This would make that surgeon very rich, but it would harm medicine overall, and harm heart surgery’s progress.
Then what happens? Let’s take the language example. “Hi, how are you?” is patented. “Hello, are you well?” is patented. “Howdy!” is patented. etc. You want to greet someone. Now you don’t just need to figure out a way to do that. You have to make sure YOUR way to greet someone is different than the thousands of patented ways to greet someone. So you have to do something like “Hey, hey, hey! Me say welcome to you! Haha! Good, yes?” this is what I meant by it getting silly. All the obvious ways to do something become patented and so you have to find some roundabout way to get the same result. Which is usually inefficient and complicated for no good reason.
Patents also do not simply stop “stealing” as you put it. If you and someone else both put in the effort to independently invent the “turns lead to gold” machine then whoever patents it first owns it. The other person, despite also putting in the effort and not even knowing you exist, just has to basically go fuck themselves.
But I’d push back on even that. You don’t own an idea. Because 99.99% of the effort to get to the point where that idea could exist was not yours. It was every other humans. You stand on the shoulders of giants and touch the stars. Then want to claim the stars as your own.
Replies (1)
-
So you basically say that patents are wrong just because we have silly patents (and even sillier laws basically).
I don’t think that “my money/time” means “something unique” but I think that if I built something new spending my money and my time then I can ask to have it protected for some years in order to be able to make some money to recover the amount I have invested to build it.
The problem is that we should have a trade-off with patents: we need to somewhat protect who invest his money to develop thing from who just copy it and undercut him and be sure that the patents do not stop innovations.
Like your surgeon example, I think that there can be right way to have patents, a good way and bad way. Now we have patents in the worst possible way. A better way would be to allow to register a patent only if you sell a product that use it and only valid for a limited time, for example.
After all, why should someone invest, say, a couple of million $ to develop something and trying to sell it at, say, 100 $ to break-even in 5 years knowing that the moment he sell someone can copy it and sell it for 20 the very next day ?
Patents also do not simply stop “stealing” as you put it. If you and someone else both put in the effort to independently invent the “turns lead to gold” machine then whoever patents it first owns it. The other person, despite also putting in the effort and not even knowing you exist, just has to basically go fuck themselves.
This is an interesting point and I agree that there is no solution with patents, the first to arrive is the winner. We maybe can have something like a grace period (if you fill a similar or equal patent in the next 2 months than both are valid) but in the end it is a race and the winner take all.
Open ##5527481