Elektrine lite

← Feed

@antoinechambertloir@mathstodon.xyz

2026-09-10 08:31 UTC

#Math #AI 3/n We have traces of mathematical activity for more than 3000 years now, so it seems that this human desire to understand, in an abstract way, our surrounding world is quite deeply ingrained in our minds. This quest has been parallel to the development of science, often prompted by questions of other sciences, but what happened in the modern era (beginning of 19th century, say), is more explicit desire for rigour in the argumentation. Not that mathematics lacked rigour, it always had a lot, like all science do, but mathematicians felt the need to have more precise definitions for their abstract objects. Mostly because standard reasoning often led mathematicians to oddities, if not mere absurdities. Let me quote just here the discovery by Bertrand Russell that if you wish to talk about collections of which things may, or may not belong, you need to be extremely careful. Russel's remark is simple: imagine you can create collections of anythings, for example collections of collections, and so on (after all, you can have a bag to keep all of your bags together…), then it might be possible that a collection be a member of itself (the idea of an idea is an idea…), and you could look at the collection R of all collections that are *not* a member of itself. This collection R is paradoxical : saying that the collection R is a member of R exactly means that it is not a member of R.

Replies (1)

  • #Math #AI 4/n After this logical disaster, mathematicians took a great more care to elaborate the way they can argue so that they don't fall into such absurdities. And they devised a way for that, which is the idea that mathematics could be (should it be?) framed in a specific *language* that is completely specified and devoid of any ambiguity. (Think about when Marx writes that “the history of all previous societies has been the history of class struggles”, what does he exactly mean by history, by societies, by class, by struggle?) This quest seems to go back to the philosopher Wilhelm Leibniz, and at the beginning of 20th century, the mathematician Giuseppe Peano suggested a very specific way of writing mathematics that, theoretically, so he believes, would solve the problem. I copy the first nine lines of his work on “natural numbers” (the numbers 1, 2, 3,…) and maybe you'll feel relieved that we don't learn to write this in high school. Moreover, mathematicians refined their model of argumentation (so called proofs) so that it fits such a specific way of being written. The outcome is called a “formal proof”, with the idea that no mathematician ever writes an actual formal proof, but that we produce an argumentation that, to the eye of a trained mathematician, could be transformed more or less mechanically into such a proof.

    Open ##5153652