2026-11-03 19:42 UTC
I really can’t see the point in teaching kids to guess or choose their own meaning of what they’re reading
I’m being sincere in saying this, I swear I’m not trying to be shitty about it: I don’t rustand how you have arrived at the conclusion that teaching kids to think critically about not just the memorized vocabulary but also the context in which new terms may be found has no benefit. Language is not static - there is no world where the english language will be exhaustively defined. As a naive example, you just did in small scale what MSV explicitly teaches people to do when you read the word ‘rustand’ above, or when you read read as read instead of read just now. MSV / Three Cueing has value through giving people a framework which they can use to apply a common framework question the grammar they are working with - it does not have value when used as a replacement for phonics, as the application of the concepts as a replacement for phonics-based education (SSM) has been repeatedly shown to be utter hokum.
This has been at the heart of the Balanced Literature division shouting match fistfight debate for ages, and although the antivaxers do seem to have won the right to assert their whackadoo definition (really, it’s just Whole Language wearing beaglepuss glasses and doing a bad german accent) as the most correct, the less outwardly insane people are still around trying to get actual reformation in the way literacy is taught.
(I’m sorry if this got rambly, I am very stressed for some unknown reason today)
Replies (0)
No replies.