Elektrine lite

← Feed

@Doomsider@lemmy.world

2026-10-17 05:29 UTC

I got that part and I agree with it. My issue is him saying don’t use a compiler if you don’t really understand the machine language it creates. This conflates LLM with a compiler as a tool when they are inherently different. This is disingenuous because it is possible understand and audit what a compiler creates. You cannot and audit what an LLM creates in even close to the same way.

Replies (2)

  • @feinstruktur@lemmy.ml 2026-10-17 06:27

    Can you elaborate on the last sentence a bit from a technical perspective? I’m not using code myself to the extent that I could really judge between LLM-generated code being good or just-works. I can just imagine compiler output being strictly deterministic, while LLM-code, due to the way a LLM works in principle, should be more …unstructured?

    Open ##5078611

  • @Ephera@lemmy.ml 2026-10-17 07:14

    But why can you not audit what the LLM creates? You can’t do it for the general case, i.e. prove that for a given prompt it always spits out a valid solution, but you can look at what it actually spit out for your concrete prompt and then you can freely decide, if those code changes are good. I am of the opinion that a thorough review often takes similarly long to actually writing it yourself, and there’s a high chance that you miss code aspects, if you don’t investigate yourself. But yeah, again, I think you’re taking the comparison too literal. He is just saying that LLMs are a tool. You need to know how to use your tool and produce objectively good results. Then he does not care what tool you use to get there.

    Open ##5078833