Elektrine lite

← Feed

@Semjeza@fedinsfw.app

2026-04-29 00:55 UTC

I suspect that what the person you replied to, meant with "meaningfully improve the lives of US citizens" was that the amount Apple contributes to the GDP of the USA (odd, since much of the goods aren't domestically produced) is disproportionately high compared to its impact on quality of life of people in the US as a whole. While I'm sure most Apple employees are paid slightly above the median wage, I don't know the median salary for an Apply employee. I also, like you, am not utilitarian enough to think that a handful of people living large in opulence makes up for the way inequality is harming living standards and the economy as whole (not to mention the impact of it all on the planet). Additionally, Apple and large companies don't buy from, or in most cases sell to individuals. They buy and sell mostly to other companies and only at the end do smaller branches or franchises sell to actual people. Mostly you have numbers and goods moving between old fashioned AIs running on human-processing power, but not actual people. * P.S. Colonialism didn't begin with international trade, because the colonies were part of the colonising nation. They begin with murder, exploitation, and appropriation of conquered territory - trade could only happen once the formerly free regions were given a colonist government with sovereignty apart from the colonist home nation. And most of them were also just corporations originally too; and many who went were coerced either directly (by violence or law) or indirectly (by economics).

Replies (2)

  • @phutatorius@lemmy.zip 2026-04-30 14:43

    >Colonialism didn’t begin with international trade, because the colonies were part of the colonising nation. That's imperialism. It's possible to establish colonies without having a motherland controlling them. Consider the original settlement of Polynesia, or the establishment of new cities by the Sea Peoples. And even when there's a motherland, it's possible that colonies will still compete with each other: for example, the Moorish kingdoms in Spain, which had roots in different ethnicities and tribes in Morocco and fought with each other like crabs in a bucket, which was why the relatively backwards Catholic Monarchs were able to eventually drive them out. It's also possible to have empires without colonization-- subverting local rulers, then pulling their strings. Much US imperialism has been like that: there's interference in Central and South America, but the US didn't replace the local elites with Yanks. They just bought them off and helped them send their kids to Harvard and Yale.

    Open ##1843005

  • @frankPodmore@slrpnk.net 2026-04-29 08:42

    >I suspect that what the person you replied to, meant with “meaningfully improve the lives of US citizens” was that the amount Apple contributes to the GDP of the USA (odd, since much of the goods aren’t domestically produced) is disproportionately high compared to its impact on quality of life of people in the US as a whole. They seemed a bit confused about the terms they were using, but your glosses don't help, I'm afraid. 'Meaningfully improve' isn't qualified but neither is your 'disproportionately high': 'disproportionate' according to whom and by what metric? A quick search suggests something like 150 million people in the US own an iPhone. It's only by engaging in complex foreign trade that Apple can make and sell their products at the price points they currently use; the foreign aspect of the trade direct impacts every one of those 150 million people by making their phones cheaper. They presumably feel their lives are improved by it. And that's just the iPhone, not counting Apple's various other products, nor the businesses that depend on those products (and the people that depend on the businesses). So, big tech arguably has a disproportionately *large* economic impact due to those dependencies. To be clear, I'm not saying this is *certainly* the case; my point is that the trade companies like Apple engage in is important, it does benefits US citizens in all kinds of ways (direct and indirect) and it makes perfect sense to use GDP as a rough measure of those impacts *alongside other metrics*. >Colonialism didn’t begin with international trade Yes, it did. It began with people trading across increasing distances, then trying to secure those trade routes (by conquering people along the way), then trying to secure the production itself at source (by conquering the regions where the products were found, grown or made). The Romans conquered the Mediterranean because it was their most important trade route; Columbus was trying to open up new trade routes.

    Open ##1843006