Elektrine lite

← Feed

@NotAnOtter@lemmus.org

2026-11-14 22:36 UTC

Ok but if trans women are biologically women because of HRT, then doesn’t that conclude trans women who don’t take HRT are biologically male? What about trans women who would take HRT given the chance but don’t for financial or medical or legislative reasons? So it the case that “trans women are biologically women” is false, since some aren’t. Or is it that “you’re not trans unless you receive HRT” - and at that point what’s your term for the people that identify as trans but don’t receive HRT for whatever reason?

Replies (2)

  • @EvilHannah@lemmy.world 2026-11-14 23:26

    You’re in an area where a binary gender model just breaks down. Whilst convenient for most people in most situations, this is like trying to use Newton’s laws of motion to understand the event horizon of a black hole. You need a different model of the world. The model I use is this: humans have many independent systems/traits within their brains and bodies, several of which are typically found in a bi-modal distribution of states which we label “male” and “female”. In trans, non-binary, and intersex people the bi-modality of that distribution starts to break down. Some systems/traits are aligned with the “male” mode, others with the “female” mode. Not all are easy or even possible to change: some are baked into how the brain works. In some of those people (trans men, trans women) it just happens that several less-visible systems/traits we cannot (or should not) change are aligned in the opposite direction to a bunch of more-visible systems/traits we can change, and that their lives become much more tolerable if they are allowed to make some changes. This usually happens via some combination of hormones & surgery, and really needs to depend on the individual because the systems/traits can be misaligned in a variety of ways and some of the treatments affect several systems in a way that cannot be quantified before treatment. If the ultimate goal of a trans man / trans woman would be to transition to better fit the classical male/female mode they would prefer, then they probably want to be labelled and treated as their preferred gender with no additional qualifications at all, but some still want their journey to be recognised so sometimes you need to ask anyway.

    Open ##5537633

  • @Cethin@lemmy.zip 2026-11-15 03:26

    You’re saying this like it’s some sort of trick. It isn’t. I’m not defending the use of “biological gender”. I’m against it. I don’t call anyone biological women/men, so it doesn’t matter if they’re on HRT. The term is not useful. Even among men and women, levels of estrogen and testosterone very. It also changes as you age. Those men who have low testosterone aren’t not men because of it. Biology is far more complex than that, so the term is useless. If they’re speaking with their doctor, their assigned gender at birth is important, but so are their hormones, and also what’s happening with their body regardless of that. To everyone else, it literally does not matter. Whatever they call themselves is all that you should care about.

    Open ##5538307