2026-04-03 09:15 UTC
@illogical_me @aredridel another way to optimize adversarial reviews is to send the author home every time you see even the slightest imperfection or questionable or just not very clear part in their code, which is a path Linux kernel takes afaik. Linux kernel is also infamous for being very hostile towards first-time contributors, despite approaching everybody the same regardless of whether it's their first contribution or not.
If you introduce Linus-style code reviews in your project, then the problem of LLMs being adversarial will be easily solved by (almost?) all LLM-generated code being rejected outright on merit. Also nobody will contribute to that project.
Replies (1)
-
@aredridel@kolektiva.social 2026-04-03 16:39
@IngaLovinde Adversarial does not have to imply abusive. The gate can in fact be high if you want it to be good. You can have dialogue to suggest improvement. And if it's not good enough _it's not good enough_.