Elektrine lite

← Feed

@wren6991@types.pl

2025-09-30 02:21 UTC

@timonsku @alvaro Because an engineer sees this circuit in the spec and says "oh so I only need one of them". It's almost irresistible. Also the same shortcut is correct in other areas, like in theory the sink detects orientation of CC1/CC2 to select the correct D-/D+ pair, but every USB 2.0 board I see just shorts the two pairs together. As far as I know this is valid.

Replies (2)

  • @wren6991@types.pl 2025-09-30 02:37

    @timonsku @alvaro The USB C spec should probably lead with "use exactly this circuit with no deviations if you just want 5V" because those are the people who will dedicate the least time to reading the spec. Committees are too excited about their favourite pet feature to think about how people use the docs they write. That schematic does exist later on (pic), and I understand the point of view that this is a normative circuit and it's your fault if you implement anything different. On the other hand the way the shorted CC lines fail with an e-marked cable is only obvious with the benefit of hindsight, so I sympathise with people who make this mistake.

    Open ##1273546

  • @timonsku@mastodon.social 2025-09-30 03:46

    @wren6991 @alvaro Not sure if D-/D+ orientation detection is even suggested, the standard calls for it to be shorted in normal circumstances. For the high speed pairs its mandatory to detect orientation

    Open ##1273560