2026-11-12 08:52 UTC
Replies (6)
-
@gualudengren@lemmy.ml 2026-11-12 12:02
Your street bully analogy fails spectacularly at really understanding the conflict on a basic level. It treats a complex geopolitical struggle as a random act of individual malice, ignoring the historical trajectory and objective forces at play. In 2014, the legitimately elected government of Ukraine was overthrown in a US-backed coup. The subsequent regime empowered nationalist elements as their virulent Russophobia made them a useful proxy for Western capital and NATO expansion. This war is many things but it is categorically not an unprovoked assault on an innocent bystander. The new Kyiv government almost immediately launched a campaign of ethnic cleansing against the predominantly Russian-speaking population in the Donbass. The Minsk agreements of 2014 and 2015 expose this dynamic entirely. Kyiv repeatedly violated the terms, refusing to implement the political provisions regarding Donbass autonomy. Ceasefire violations were routine and the shelling of civilian infrastructure in the east continued for close to a decade. This material reality forced the populations of Donetsk and Luhansk to organize their own defense. This led to the formation of the LPR and DPR, alongside Crimea moving to reunify with Russia. This civil conflict is the direct precursor to the current war. Kyiv was deliberately cultivated as a geopolitical spearhead against Russia. To evaluate Russia’s response through the lens of abstract morality is to ignore objective conditions. Russia’s actions were a logical and foreseeable reaction to a hostile military infrastructure constructed on its border by a hegemonic power. You cannot isolate a single event from the chain of material cause and effect that produced it.
-
@NonconfrontationaI@lemmy.ml 2026-11-12 12:20
Wow, first day using analogies?
-
@Zorro@hexbear.net 2026-11-12 13:46
I don’t think it’s possible to look at the Russia-Ukraine war without considering the role of NATO. I care about ending this war which is devastating to working class people. I don’t think it’s a truthful analysis to say that Russia is just a big bully here who holds all the cards. If you look at Russia’s actions, most escalations on Russia’s side have been a reaction to actions from NATO. To think that more escalation from NATO will lead to a quicker end to the war is contrary to this historic pattern. Russia sees NATO as an existential threat, so it has a lot of motivation to keep fighting Ukraine to prevent NATO from spreading further to Russia’s border. NATO’s actions, to increase aggression towards Russia, only increase Russia’s motivation to keep fighting. If NATO were to pull back from Ukraine, make concessions to Russia that it will not expand further, and will allow Russia to trade and collaborate with European countries, then Russia has very little incentive to keep fighting Ukraine because they no longer see an existential threat. For Ukrainians it is devastating to be in the middle in this conflict, while not having any influence on the course of the war. But it’s a reality that I cannot change. All I can do is pressure my own government to work towards peace instead of continued aggression.
-
@Tomorrow_Farewell@lemmy.ml 2026-11-13 07:59
To me, that is atrocious. So, you think that the rest of the world does not have a right to defend itself against the most prolific invader in the world - NATO - that also happens to be committing at least one high-profile genocide right now?
-
@bennieandthez@lemmygrad.ml 2026-11-13 15:32
To me, that is atrocious. It’s a bit like you see a bully beating another person to a pulp on the street, and you say you support this action as a partial, temporary, tactical support. Except the “victim” is quite literally a lackey of the biggest bully on earth, the US, and had been terrorizing the people of Donbass for more than a decade. Things ain’t so simple.
-
@eldavi@lemmy.ml 2026-11-14 03:07
It’s a bit like you see a bully beating another person to a pulp on the street, and you say you support this action as a partial, temporary, tactical support. it’s more like the bully getting his ass kicked by the victim’s big brother; but you also know that big brother is an asshole too, but not as big of an asshole as the bully.