2026-09-06 04:36 UTC
This and the comment it replies to make the categorical error which is to assume that NAT exists as part-and-parcel to firewalling. This is not the case. Many American university and corporate networks do still adhere to the end-to-end principle by giving every device a public IP address. They can do this because they are among the few legacy entities that actually have enough for their needs, such as a Class A (aka /8) subnet on Legacy IP. At the same time, these entities employ firewalls that don’t allow unsolicited inbound traffic (and sometimes also block disallowed outbound traffic).
NAT is not a firewall, and the OP correctly points out that by using NAT or CGNAT, the end to end principle is demolished, with no way to for the victims to recover. OP mentions “firewalls” exactly twice, to compare how they are not firewalls and are still necessary in spite of NAT. Nobody is credibly suggesting that everyone should switch to IPv6 without a firewall. Every single domestic router for the past two decades has included a firewall, and that would not change in an all IPv6 world.
Replies (0)
No replies.