Elektrine lite

← Feed

@XiJinpingStanAccount@lemmy.ml

2026-11-11 20:13 UTC

Well yes, but proprietary only works with patents. All it means without them is you have to decompile it and reverse engineer it. Which is pretty easy to do these days. But I’d push back on the idea of “The same code you made” being special. Code is just language and math put together. Take a sentence. “Hi, how are you?” under patent rules once someone patents that specific way to say this nobody else can do it. You can do the same function but have to phrase it differently. Like “Hello, are you well?” and eventually this just gets silly. Being the first to do something the most obvious way to do it shouldn’t give you a right to not let anyone else do it that way. My argument is based on a fundamentally different way of viewing invention. Many people think of it as a singular inventor/genius coming up with an idea nobody had before, and then anyone else who has the same idea after them is “stealing” it. This is just silly imo. That inventor is not special. Inventions do not happen because someone has a special idea. They happen because the material conditions exist to make them possible. You wouldn’t invent the car before the steam engine for example. Or the book before paper. Take Calculus. Isaac Newton and Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz were getting to the same conclusion (inventing calculus) around the same time entirely independently. Because it just so happened they were alive at the right time to do so. In general inventions will arise some time after the conditions to create them exist. This relies on the work of all human civilization prior, and so these inventions should be the collective property of all humanity. If one accepts the premise that discovery is an inevitable result of material conditions, the moral and economic justification for patents collapses. In this framework, the patent holder isn’t being rewarded for creating something that otherwise wouldn’t exist; they are being rewarded for being the first to reach a finish line that many others were already approaching. The patent then functions as a tool to capture a monopoly over a natural progression of knowledge, effectively taxing society for a discovery that would have happened regardless. I’m not really trying to argue with you here btw. Just explaining my complete view on the topic. I get that you might agree with some of this, and disagree with some. I just wanted you to have a full picture of where I’m coming from.

Replies (2)

  • @hperrin@lemmy.ca 2026-11-12 03:03

    Your view I feel would only work in a communist, or at least extremely socialist, society. Under the American form of capitalism, that would essentially make being an inventor worthless. Whatever you invent will just be copied by the biggest competitor in the field. A system of necessary monopolies. I don’t disagree that your view (under a system of extreme socialism) is a better way to set up a society than American capitalism. But unless we abolish capitalism, I think what you’re arguing for is worse for the proletariat than what we have.

    Open ##5521851

  • @gian@lemmy.grys.it 2026-11-12 13:58

    But I’d push back on the idea of “The same code you made” being special. Code is just language and math put together. Take a sentence. “Hi, how are you?” under patent rules once someone patents that specific way to say this nobody else can do it. You can do the same function but have to phrase it differently. Like “Hello, are you well?” and eventually this just gets silly. Being the first to do something the most obvious way to do it shouldn’t give you a right to not let anyone else do it that way. Why not ? In the end I used my money to come up with a way to do things, I would argue that I am entitled to stop someone else to simply stole it and I can always license you my work so we both can make some money, you selling something without the need to reinvent it, I selling you something so I can recover my initial expense. (which is the idea behind patents in the first place) The point would be to not have silly patents in the first place.

    Open ##5523801