Elektrine lite

← Feed

@thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social

2022-11-18 22:56 UTC

French authorities declare the use of Microsoft Office and Google Docs illegal in schools and education markets, as they don’t follow GDPR and might disturb later competition by making students used to these proprietary solutions. https://questions.assemblee-nationale.fr/q16/16-971QE.htm

Replies (40)

  • @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social 2022-11-18 22:59

    Looks like it only applies to Office365 online and Google docs, not the installed MS Office suite. The fact that these companies are US based means there is no guarantee that student’s data isn’t accessed by the US government, which seems to be the main issue.

    Open ##2587161

  • @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social Wow that is amazing! Hopefully other countries follow

    Open ##2587203

  • @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social if students use cryptpad/only office/nextcloud that'd be amazing

    Open ##2587204

  • @elise@potate.space 2022-11-18 22:58

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social oh wow, let’s now hope they ban photoshop :blobcatsip:

    Open ##2587205

  • @yoavzack@pirsamti.com 2022-11-18 22:58

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social finally, some light with this microsoft tunnel. This should have happened a long time ago!

    Open ##2587206

  • @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social let's hope that turns into policy before the corporate lobbying machines mobilise.

    Open ##2587207

  • @IngoKueper@mastodon.social 2022-11-18 23:08

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social that is basically the status quo in Germany for the past years. It would be nice if they would invest in alternatives. Even if it is indirect through education and training. People wouldn't be afraid of alternatives like nextcloud once they have used it. From my perspective it is not enough to ban products from companies that make money with your data we should also start promoting alternatives.

    Open ##2587210

  • @gianni@disobey.net 2022-11-18 23:03

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social I hope this doesn’t mean schools switch en masse to local MS Office … would feel like a step in the wrong direction. Libreoffice FTW

    Open ##2587211

  • @LukasBrausch@030.me 2022-11-18 23:05

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social The right decision! In Germany, we could really learn a lot from this bold but necessary move.

    Open ##2587214

  • @Anton_1@techhub.social 2022-11-18 23:07

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social to bad the US government seems to be clueless about this kind of stuff

    Open ##2587215

  • @makeratschool@kanoa.de 2022-11-18 23:14

    #FediLZ Mit Anlauf ...

    Open ##2587218

  • @makeratschool@kanoa.de 2022-11-18 23:18

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social @arawa@pouet.chapril.org Looks like a great opportunity for #FOSS

    Open ##2587219

  • @lps@masto.1146.nohost.me 2022-11-18 23:31

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social it's almost like this was their plan;)

    Open ##2587220

  • @dieTasse@troet.cafe 2022-11-18 23:42

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social nice

    Open ##2587221

  • @SRAZKVT@tech.lgbt 2022-11-18 23:48

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social hmmm, no google docs ? i wonder what dtudents collaborating on work will use instead, being able to be multiple people editing a single file at the same time without needing to put mondy on it, is something all students generally want. Definitely better than what we had where 1 student only put everyone else's things in the document.

    Open ##2587222

  • @Zelfir@noc.social 2022-11-19 00:01

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social Il était temps !

    Open ##2587223

  • @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social Does this really mean they are being declared illegal?

    Open ##5410843

  • @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social HOLY. That's actually pretty crazy. 10 points to France!

    Open ##5410845

  • @tilvids@mstdn.social 2022-11-19 00:45

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social This seems like really reasonable policy. O365 and Google Docs are still legal and companies are welcome to use them; however public entities should strive to use open software when possible.

    Open ##5410846

  • @sufw@mastodon.social 2022-11-19 00:46

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social and here I thought Germany had the monopoly on this particular kind of crazy! 🤪

    Open ##5410847

  • @kikobar@acc4e.com 2022-11-19 00:59

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social Great news! #OpenSource rocks!

    Open ##5410849

  • @darkbandits6@mstdn.social 2022-11-19 01:16

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social Here here! Let's get other countries in on breaking the big tech oligopoly's ability to squash innovation before it even begins!

    Open ##5410850

  • @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social C'est la meilleure nouvelle technologique de cette année.

    Open ##5410851

  • @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social Great news!

    Open ##5410855

  • @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social I'd like to think this will convince at lesst a few school districts to go open source. Like maybe moodle, nextcloud, onlyoffice, libreoffice, and whatever else. Though I kind of doubt it since only well funded districts with an IT team passionate about open source would bother attempting this. Unfortunately, the simpler solution would be to use canvas and ask for MS office files.

    Open ##5410859

  • @aldi80s@mastodon.social 2022-11-19 02:31

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social What is GDPR? However that's the most beautiful new I could read today!!!

    Open ##5410860

  • @TheFrirish@h4.io 2022-11-19 03:11

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social This news actually made my day.

    Open ##5410868

  • @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social ouch. I wonder how much they were used.

    Open ##5410870

  • @arcdaniel@fosstodon.org 2022-11-19 05:24

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social here in Luxembourg, I have the feeling that the government has sold there soul to MS. Every child from the first school year (so with 3-4 years old), they become automatically an Office365 license...

    Open ##5410873

  • @davevader@det.social 2022-11-19 07:16

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social The whole concept of using proprietary solutions for basic infrastructure in public settings has always seemed a bit strange to me.

    Open ##5410874

  • @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social @stephen Actually when I retweeted Hanff’s post about this on the bird site I got pushback saying his and your summary is inaccurate. What has been called into question is a version that would be used for free by adults, not the reduced metadata gobbling version used in schools. https://twitter.com/m4rchmain/status/1592967321857200128

    Open ##5410875

  • @Dogmaster6@techhub.social 2022-11-19 08:15

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social If only the US government would do the same. Instead most schools are going in a somewhat backward direction, in fact, the federal government gives computer discounts to schools that employ significant tracking to "keep kids safe." A school filter that blocks duckduckgo + private search engines is not "keeping children safe." Also most US schools use microsoft/google products so enjoy being datamined.

    Open ##5410880

  • @el_nino@techhub.social 2022-11-19 08:27

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social It would be great for other EU countries to go on the same direction.

    Open ##5410885

  • @JoeF@dice.camp 2022-11-19 09:28

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social Meanwhile in Croatia state school workers get free Office365 licences 😂

    Open ##5410887

  • @n770@ruhr.social 2022-11-19 09:51

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social #FediLZ #twlz

    Open ##5410889

  • @dastofu@mastodon.art 2022-11-19 10:07

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social gods i wish that were the case here, it is painful to see uni professors struggle with not properly unlocked licenses, and I just don't understand how people are trusting google with sometimes extremely sensitive data, that many of them can't even access offline. Good on france, really. I simply don't get why so many institutions accept the expensive microsoft deals

    Open ##5410891

  • @everythingeeb@fosstodon.org 2022-11-19 10:57

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social Good. This is exactly what needs to happen

    Open ##5410892

  • @ADaskalov@techhub.social 2022-11-19 10:59

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social Don't know if I agree with this particular case. I'm all for not using that much proprietary software, but Google and Microsoft make it really easy for admins in schools and universities, plus the added benefit of having web apps available. I think until there's an open source alternative that is at least as good, this is a drastic move.

    Open ##5410893

  • @paolog@mastodon.social 2022-11-19 10:59

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social Vorrei commentare in italiano (sorry for the English speaking people) a beneficio dei lettori italiofoni per aprire un dibattito sulla rilevanza istituzionale dell'interrogazione parlamentare in oggetto. Il problema andrebbe posto anche da noi, relativamente a tutti i servizi cloud gratuiti usati o pubblicizzati da soggetti istituzionali. Ad esempio quali sono le implicazioni della presenza di loghi/link Facebook, Twitter e Instagram sulla home page Rainews https://www.rainews.it ?

    Open ##5410896

  • @aral@mastodon.ar.al 2022-11-19 11:17

    @thelinuxEXP@mastodon.social Excellent news and spot on.

    Open ##5410898