Elektrine lite

← Feed

@dhkuq3645@lemmy.dbzer0.com

2026-10-22 18:19 UTC

yes you can verity that it is secure by reverse engineering, just like someone can read the code, someone can reverse engineer it. And I’m not saying that WhatsApp isn’t encrypted, but we can’t know if this also applies properly to metadata, or which encryption algorithm is actually used, if the keys are really only accessible to end users (i.e. if it’s really E2EE), etc. It DOESN’T, they literally state that they don’t have encrypt metadata and can share it with other meta services which honestly as long as the messages themselves are encrypted is sadly still a much better option than sms Of course there’s still a level of trust required regarding Signal’s operational integrity, as we can’t know if this is really what runs on their servers, but at least the Signal Foundation doesn’t have a history of countless known privacy violations like Meta does, which means it all comes down to how much you trust either of those organisations thanks for proving you don’t know, even the signal server doesn’t know ur contacts… signal.org/blog/private-contact-discovery/ …signal.org/…/360007061452-Does-Signal-send-my-nu… As for the hardware: Assuming that there is indeed some component spying on me, why would this be a justification to become careless about privacy on the software level? because it’d be above everything else and could see everything, no matter the sw ur using… so it’d be pointless anyways And it’s unlikely for there to be anything on the hardware level that could be spying without anyone noticing, at least if we assume that this hardware would send this data somewhere, which one would surely notice when analysing network traffic or by checking for emitted radio frequencies if the manufacturer had the genius idea of using mesh networks instead. Just like

Replies (1)

  • @Spectrism@lemmy.dbzer0.com 2026-10-22 23:11

    yes you can verity that it is secure by reverse engineering, just like someone can read the code, someone can reverse engineer it. No, you can’t, at least not reliably. Reverse engineering is nowhere near as simple as “just like someone can read the code”. It DOESN’T, they literally state that they don’t have encrypt metadata and can share it with other meta services I don’t keep up with whatever WhatsApp is doing, so nice to know that it’s already worse than I thought, but it doesn’t really change my point. which honestly as long as the messages themselves are encrypted is sadly still a much better option than sms If I could be certain that the messages are in fact encrypted as claimed, I’d agree. thanks for proving you don’t know, even the signal server doesn’t know ur contacts… They do, just not in the way you probably think. Unique identifiers (which phone numbers typically are) can always be used to track users, even if they’re just stored as a hash value on a server. They don’t immediately reveal the identity of a person like clear text phone numbers could do, but there’s still information that can be extracted through metadata analysis. Though to be fair, this discussion is more relevant to anonymity than to privacy. because it’d be above everything else and could see everything, no matter the sw ur using… so it’d be pointless anyways Why would it be pointless? If some random person broke into your home, would you just open all the doors because apparently doors are pointless? Having one entity spy on you is a weird excuse to let another one do the same. I mean… you do you, but I think it’s a weird mentality to have. Just like with whatsapp… Not really, as any unwanted traffic to WhatsApp’s servers would just get drowned within wanted traffic, making it effectively unnoticeable to the user. The same can’t be said for hardware that tries to connect somewhere despite no software on that device being allowed to connect to the internet.

    Open ##5205538