Elektrine lite

← Feed

@Virginicus__dup_31723@universeodon.com

2026-02-28 18:55 UTC

@ajcain@mathstodon.xyz Physics does have a different standard of beauty from the one you’ve been talking about up to today. More like, it should be nice and compact and work really well. One big reason we think Maxwell’s equations are beautiful is that they didn’t need to be updated when Relativity came along.c

Replies (1)

  • @ajcain@mathstodon.xyz 2026-03-01 10:44

    @Virginicus I completely agree that physics has different standards of beauty from mathematics per se. In physics, the beauty can involve not just the mathematical formulation, but also considerations like visualizability, conceptual commitments (what is posited to exist, etc.), and, as you say, how well it works (empirical adequacy, ease of use, stability under changing theoretical underpinnings). That said, there are quite a few instances of physicists asserting that mathematical beauty can be a guide to correctness in physics. Dirac is probably the most famous example, although his open proselytizing for mathematical beauty came *after* his own most productive period. In my work on the history of mathematical beauty, when I looked at physics, I specifically focused only on *mathematical* beauty. A general study of the role of beauty in physics (or the physical sciences more broadly) would be another book.

    Open ##1670117