Elektrine lite

← Feed

@savvie@lemmy.zip

2026-11-08 17:18 UTC

Why blue WA voted to ban trans athletes from girls sports Opponents say [Washington state] voters were persuaded at least partly because the initiative and its boosters exploited deep-seated prejudices and misunderstandings about transgender people to erode their rights. …Now things are poised to change for all girls who want to compete in girls sports at public schools and some private schools, because I-638 says they must provide medical documentation confirming their “biological sex.” The definition of “biological sex” is disputed, and how exactly that requirement will play out in practice is unclear, with some opponents alarmed it could force some girls to undergo pelvic exams.

Replies (10)

  • @krathalan@lemmy.blahaj.zone 2026-11-09 06:09

    As a WA resident I would like to add: “The largest donor to support Initiative 638, Brian Heywood, hedge fund manager and founder of Let’s Go Washington, the Political Action Committee (PAC) leading the campaign in support of Initiative 638, contributed about $2.23 million. … Supporters have received $7.74 million, while opponents have received about $2.16 million.” ballotpedia.org/Washington_Initiative_638,_Sex_Ve… This fuck has a history of trying to control children: “The unprecedented initiative slate would … guarantee parents access to information on K-12 school curricula and school medical records.” seattletimes.com/…/6-initiatives-head-to-wa-ballo… He’s like our own state version of Elon Musk.

    Open ##5548510

  • @Nouvellalia@lemmy.world 2026-11-09 06:54

    If we lived in a world where people really cared about girl’s and women’s sports, and fairness, this would be dealt with using science and logic. The sex divisions in sports are really “dominant hormone” divisions. So anyone who has started puberty must be divided into the league with which their hormones align. The studies say that a trans woman who has been at cis female levels of estrogen and testosterone for two years, has no advantage over a cis woman. That’s the criteria. Two years, then good luck. It’s not hard.

    Open ##5549313

  • @Vespair@lemmy.zip 2026-11-09 13:07

    Obviously trans people should have full rights and opportunities to participate in society in any way the rest of us can. But beyond and aside from that, I will never understand why we have to act like sports are some sacred thing whose purity must be protected. It’s people playing with a ball. I genuinely can’t imagine why this issue has ever been anything other than “yes let whoever wants to play with the ball play with the ball.” It is truly weird to me how we not only accept the sports cult, but literally never even scrutinize the field. It’s grown-ups playing children games; it’s definitely not that serious

    Open ##5549976

  • @Rentlar@lemmy.ca 2026-11-08 17:46

    I want to make clear that I support trans people participating in any recreational activity, I support their rights as much as anyone, and that this initiative throws a burden on all female children for the sake of a punishing a few, the competitiveness argument is totally based on assumptions and prejudice not backed by fact-based evidence, the issue is pushed by conservative culture war propagandists, and all that. That all said, I don’t think most WA voters who voted for I-638 did so because they hate trans people, or think they shouldn’t exist as people. Hateful and spiteful people do exist but they are a minority. Rather, on this specific wedge issue, again based on flawed prejudice pushed by conservatives, opinions seem more to be framed around something similar to why 40 year olds can’t compete in an Over-50 bracket of a tournament.

    Open ##5549981

  • @billwashere@lemmy.world 2026-11-09 01:20

    It’s really not that difficult to understand. I’m very liberal but if I was a parent of a teenage girl, I would also be worried about the size and muscle difference in a teenage boy that has just started transitioning. But I also don’t think anyone should be banned from playing sports just because they are transgender. The easiest solution in my mind is just make weight divisions like they do in wrestling for example. My boy wrestled in high school and I would have been just as concerned with him wrestling some of those “grown ass men” in high school. Remove gender requirements and make weight classes, maybe weight and size limits, or maybe just an open division if the participants/parents aren’t worried for any sport that someone might get hurt because of the size difference. There isn’t a perfect solution but I do understand the concern.

    Open ##5550008

  • @PangurBan@lemmy.world 2026-11-09 22:15

    We have weight classes for certain sports. Why not do that with everything? There’s differences between lots of people. I have two coworkers who are both cis men but one is 6.5ft and the other is 5.7ft with probably 200lbs difference between them… Why single out trans people? Why not just, you know, be more fair period if that’s the actual goal. And then we don’t have to deal with creepy ass “prove your sex to me” bullshit. So tired of how dumb and incompetent everyone is anymore…

    Open ##5550753

  • @NotAnOtter@lemmus.org 2026-11-09 17:45

    I wish people The Good Side were open to more nuanced conversations on this topic. There are many reasons why you could oppose trans athletes in girls sports that have nothing to do with transphobia but when that conversation is placed next to the foghorn of hate from The Bad Side, nuance dies.

    Open ##5550889

  • @AdolfSchmitler@lemmy.world 2026-11-09 17:41

    Are there even any trans kids playing high school sports in Washington?? Cuz if not then all this did was inconvenience cis high school girls lol “Sorry but Susie can’t play since she didn’t turn in her gender verification form on time”

    Open ##5551218

  • This thread sure turned into a dumpster fire.

    Open ##5551376

  • @Malica@lemmy.zip 2026-11-09 22:17

    I hope this gets thrown out on the basis of sex discrimination

    Open ##5552112