Elektrine lite

← Feed

@panda_abyss@lemmy.ca

2026-10-16 19:57 UTC

I got banned from the Fuck AI community for saying Linus isn’t stupid. Not that he’s right on AI, just that he’s not stupid. Indeed, the atmosphere is toxic. We’re on a site where people happily discuss their arr stack or transpiring the PS5 system, but bemoan AI is killing artists and coding. There are real ethical issues, job impacts, environmental issues, property rights issues (real and intellectual), privacy, a stack of cards economy etc. But there is also utility, and frankly the genie is out of the bottle. For better or worse. Catching kernel bugs in Linux with AI should be seen as a good because they’re not being exploited offensively by private actors. AI review that catches the most annoying 80% of errors or issues saves human time, while not contributing slop to the kernel. There is a lot to discuss if you show up in good faith. Also, Linus is an asshole. Why would anyone be surprised he reacted like an asshole? His point on his expectations is actually clear and sensible to me. He probably could have said just that, but he’s an asshole, and acting how you would expect after a bunch of people are yelling at him.

Replies (4)

  • @Someonelol@lemmy.dbzer0.com 2026-10-16 20:51

    Nuance is a hard concept to get in most Lemmy comment threads. It’s obvious it’s just a tool that uses an insane amount of resources that can do some good in certain applications. The problem stems from it being abused for evil and stupid things. Can AI be used to help flag cancerous growths in x rays and help save lives? Absolutely! Can it also be used to track every human being on the planet for surveillance purposes while its proponents build massive biome-destroying data centers to act as the infrastructure? It sure can! All that said, I still don’t feel confident about rolling in AI code to open source projects when bots aren’t accountable to their contributions. They should require a huge amount of oversight which I doubt is happening at the moment.

    Open ##5069730

  • @webghost0101@sopuli.xyz 2026-10-16 22:21

    I got banned from saying not all that is called ai is bad by giving video game npcs from the last decades as an example.

    Open ##5070872

  • @Dreamcatcher@lemmy.zip 2026-10-16 22:54

    Just don’t engage with any community that starts with “fuck” if you have any kind of nuance for the subject matter. It’s not a great time. If you don’t get banned, you’ll get dogpiled with angry and idiotic comments anyway, by people that have decided their own facts already.

    Open ##5071176

  • @whoisearth@lemmy.ca 2026-10-17 00:15

    All the fuckX communities are toxic for the same reason. No nuance. No complexity. Binary. The world is not black & white it’s shades of grey.

    Open ##5072050