2026-11-13 06:25 UTC
That’s the simplest way that this is wrong. But it’s also wrong in a much more interesting way that even a bunch of scientists I interact with don’t quite get sometimes.
You can talk about the current complex system that has built up a bunch of internal dependencies over time, and wrongly talk about the odds of the specific sequence with all that embedded history appearing all at once.
But you can also talk about canalization, and the metaphors from erosion are very apt and very intentional. If you have a hillside where it rains, there are a huge number of drainage networks that can transfer water down the hill, and any one of them is only a tiny space of possibilities. But also, if you take a hillside and bulldoze it, you WILL get one of those valid networks back again, and it does not have to happen all at once. Instead, small changes to the inert starting point will be driven into existence by the pressures of the flowing water, causing the flow to slightly increase. Those highly contingent starting points will then drive an accelerating process of secondary changes that pushes the hillside towards an efficient drainage network, regardless of the starting point. The system is driven very predictably into a tiny corner of parameter space, from a huge number of initial starting points.
There are very persuasive arguments that abiogenesis and evolution are very similar. Initially inert chemistry subject to disequilibrium being driven into becoming an efficient metabolic channel, and an efficient information channel, pushing you towards the living state in an initial environment.
I recommend looking for the work of one particular guy, Dr. Eric Smith. There’s an old talk of his somewhere on youtube, where to roughly paraphrase, he says that you shouldn’t be wondering about the very specific chemical events at the origin of life, but instead, you should “ask what was so wrong with the dead Earth that it had to spontaneously break down into the living Earth”
Replies (1)
-
@o7___o7@awful.systems 2026-11-13 15:38
canalized is now my word of the day