Elektrine lite

← Feed

@Semjeza@fedinsfw.app

2026-04-29 14:30 UTC

Maybe I'm biased, but I find it hard to believe that those 150 million (nearly half the population of the US?) would see a notable drop in the quality of their lives if their iPhones were Samsung, or Huawai, or any other non-domestic company's. You're right in that "meaningfully improve" and "disproportionate" aren't precise or scientific terms, either. And re: colonialism, I think more people have managed international trade without going coloniser than did, so it can't be seen as the sole origin. Needs more to germinate. On the main issue, I'd say while GDP is far from perfect, it's better to have the measure than not. Even if it works best as part of a range of measures and not over relied upon as it tends to be in popular understandings at the moment, in my view anyhow. Temper it with more inequality stats, and also median wages vs. cost of living.

Replies (1)

  • @phutatorius@lemmy.zip 2026-04-30 14:49

    > I think more people have managed international trade without going coloniser than did, so it can’t be seen as the sole origin. Yeah, it's a continuum. Consider the Vikings: they'd do raiding, they'd set up trading posts, they'd do elite replacement, and sometimes they'd move in with their families, do farming and set up businesses. It's also the case that internal power dynamics within the elites would sometimes shift non-coercive trade to something more coercive, a small faction would benefit hugely, but on a wider scale, it'd be a net loss for the nation doing it. Maintaining a long-term military occupation with a lengthy logistic chain isn't cheap, and unanticipated changes in circumstances can drive the cost for higher. That's one of the causes of the collapse of empires.

    Open ##1843008