Elektrine lite

← Feed

@tao@mathstodon.xyz

2026-08-04 06:10 UTC

In my recent ICM talk in https://teorth.github.io/tao-web/slides/age-of-ai-icm-2026.pdf, I highlighted the five stages of proof development and maturation: proof generation, proof verification, proof exposition, proof publication, and proof canonicalization. This developmental cycle is somewhat analogous to the developmental cycle of a living being, from an infant, to a child, to an adolescent, and finally to an adult; cf. Cedric Villani's popular book "Birth of a Theorem". As mentioned in those slides, it is the final "adult" stage of having canonical, textbook proofs that is the most valuable for applications (and for generating further proof methods). To continue this analogy, the authors of a proof have traditionally played a role somewhat similar to that of parents or caretakers, first bringing a proof into the world, and then investing significant effort into growing and improving that proof in various dimensions, such as readability, conceptual clarity, or insightfulness. The acclaim that mathematicians have historically received for creating a difficult new proof is based in part on this expectation of continued investment in the development of that proof, and its surrounding ideas and theory. (1/2)

Replies (3)

  • @tao@mathstodon.xyz 2026-08-04 06:10

    It is therefore disturbing to see the recent trend of proofs being abandoned at an intermediate stage of their developmental process, for instance by an individual or company using AI tools to first generate and then verify a proof, but then showing no inclination to contribute any further to its future development and maturation, for instance by giving talks about the results, or going through the peer review process to publish them. In some cases, other mathematicians have volunteered to take over these duties to ensure that the proof does end up being a meaningful contribution to the literature; but this hardly speaks well of the original "parents" of such a proof. When it comes to actual parenthood, there is a very strong cultural norm that the parents of a child are responsible for raising that child to full adulthood. In this new era of proof abundance, I propose that the analogous norm for proofs, which held in practice in the past, be made explicit: any author seeking to claim credit for generating a proof should commit to making their best efforts to develop that proof all the way to at least the publication stage. (This includes the prior exposition stage, which involves things like giving talks about the result.) (2/2)

    Open ##5160731

  • @tao@mathstodon.xyz You can summarise all that as simply decoupling of insight generation for the community, from the end result. Unfortunately, due to the social-economic-political aspect of it all, paths of least resistance, etc. -- the new reality will be an insight-on-effort/ "insight monopoly" (IMO). No matter how you try, even with your laurels , it seems everyone is determined to race to this future.

    Open ##5160759

  • @rzeta0@mathstodon.xyz 2026-08-05 08:31

    @tao@mathstodon.xyz We must be careful not to create new high walls around the discipline because the old ones were knocked down and the undeserving barbarians can now do what previously required gatekeeping initiation ceremonies from the academic establishment. ---- (I'm no fan of earth burning AI that has human deskilliing as a side effect, my observation is about academia)

    Open ##5160760