2023-10-09 12:54 UTC
@SmartmanApps@dotnet.social I've been pondering this for a few days. The way I see it in my mind is most/all agree that 8 ÷ 2a has precedence for (2 × a). Then if a = 1 + b, how would you substitute that into the first equation. You would write 8 ÷ 2(1 + b), and so it must be the case that expanding out the brackets has precedence. At this point you can't really deny that if b = 3, you would do anything differently.
Replies (2)
-
@dm319@fosstodon.org 2023-10-09 13:28
@SmartmanApps@dotnet.social Also I found this thesis published this year on teacher's understanding of the order of operations which you may find interesting / rage about 😆 https://eprints.qut.edu.au/240795/
-
@SmartmanApps@dotnet.social 2023-10-09 19:11
@dm319@fosstodon.org 1. exactly right. That's exactly the meaning of having Terms. 2a is 1 term, 2*a is 2 terms. 2. there are still people who don't understand Terms - Lennes' 1917 letter being the classic case - and argue that 2a is 2*a, not (2*a) (and even Lennes admitted himself that literally all textbooks did it that way, but somehow he didn't realise he was missing the point).