2026-05-12 11:38 UTC
Replies (1)
-
@tao@mathstodon.xyz 2026-05-13 12:33
@wikiemol@mathstodon.xyz Problem solving and theory building are in fact highly synergistic. I can continue the food analogy with this quote from Erdos, often regarded as a quintessential "problem solver": "A well-chosen problem can isolate an essential difficulty in a particular area, serving as a benchmark against which progress in this area can be measured. It might be like a 'marshmallow', serving as a tasty tidbit supplying a few moments of fleeting enjoyment. Or it might be like an 'acorn', requiring deep and subtle new insights from which a mighty oak can develop." To continue the analogy further, current levels of AI technology are like blenders that can now produce significant amounts of paste consisting of both ground up marshmallows and ground up acorns, which can score well on such benchmark metrics as edibility, nutrient value, and digestibility, yet remain distinctly unappetizing. As the technology improves, the flavor and acorn content of this paste may get better, but - as you say - this is still insufficient to generate oaks. Nevertheless, I do not believe that the solution to this issue is to ban blenders and food processors, or decry them as evil, but to view them as highly situational tools for cooking - very useful in certain scenarios, when used responsibly, but wholly inappropriate for use in others. Furthermore, the culture of racing to be the first to produce an edible substance will need to be de-emphasized in favor of a more holistic approach to the broader objectives of sustainable food production, preparation, and cultivation.