Elektrine lite

← Feed

@eloquence@social.coop

2022-11-07 05:39 UTC

The collapse of Twitter is a system breakdown. Mastodon and the fediverse represent something different: _system change_. From for-profit "Big Tech" to nonprofit, open source, community-owned public spaces. System change is always harder than you think. It always incurs short-term costs, with hoped for long-term benefits. The next few weeks will be really tough for the fediverse. Stick around, vibe with it, and you just might help us put a huge part of the web back in community hands. <3

Replies (40)

  • @eloquence@social.coop 2022-11-07 05:48

    Expect some of the following to happen in the coming weeks: - celebrities with huge follower counts pushing tiny community-run servers to their knees - instance admin burnout; shutting down of servers - big new servers that don't "vibe" with common rules or culture being widely defederated - some notable account violating an instance code of conduct and throwing a fit - lots of people ragequitting Mastodon for one reason or another - etc. It'll be a rough ride. Patience and strength, all.

    Open ##2961470

  • @greenback@mastodon.social 2022-11-07 07:09

    @eloquence@social.coop It feels like being part of a real cultural moment on here. I love Mastodon in a way that I never even liked Twitter, so I'm definitely sticking around!

    Open ##5350703

  • @eloquence@social.coop Will this be like the big WhatsApp rush, when people left to Signal, and then all came right back to WhatsApp?

    Open ##5350709

  • @immota@mastodon.social 2022-11-07 08:41

    @eloquence@social.coop I expect / hope also a separate site listing Mastodon accounts of popular Twitter users to emerge to improve account discoverability. And that some of those accounts will be fake.

    Open ##5350710

  • @fernby@mastodon.sdf.org 2022-11-07 08:53

    @eloquence@social.coop here’s hoping, honestly.

    Open ##5350713

  • @eloquence@social.coop how are people covering the costs of servers? It costs us $600 a month to host an active Discourse forum, and seen a few things about instances closing. Curious how it will be sustainable.

    Open ##5350714

  • @eloquence@social.coop I’m not sure that this kind of a system change can be sustainable in the long run. If people are quitting Twitter because they need to pay $8, and Fediverse requires some kind of donations to keep things running… also at some level, if instance’s community will grow then server may need more than one admin. Maybe some DEV, then DB specialist to help with optimisation, more people for moderation. And here we go into the “we need some ppl to pay for it” situation. I think that it would be good to have alternatives but if too many people will move here, the all bot farms and spammers will came too. And it’s Twitter all over again… I really appreciate that right now there is less of us here.

    Open ##5350715

  • @sailhpy@mastodon.ie 2022-11-07 09:54

    @eloquence@social.coop The interesting part is the community limits per instance. There’s a function of human and machine bandwidth. And what happens when we run out of one or other. A lot of instances will fail quickly I reckon (remember the Fail Whale?) Maybe it will evolve into what I hoped Wave would turn out to be. I still hope.

    Open ##5350717

  • @johnnymojo@mastodon.uno 2022-11-07 10:23

    @eloquence@social.coop Make sure to give a little back- even €1/month from each user makes a difference! @pi4630@mastodon.uno

    Open ##5350718

  • @eloquence@social.coop This seems the direction of travel. No adverts. The clunkiness will go. Hopefully interesting content.

    Open ##5350719

  • @smadre75@mas.to 2022-11-07 10:37

    @eloquence@social.coop I’m truly hoping for the best. I came over from Birdland a few hours ago. It’s going to take a bit to get used to the differences, but I’m so glad this exists. I already feel calmer. I wish everyone good luck and success with the platform as the exodus continues. 🙏🏾

    Open ##5350720

  • @Geogger@mastodon.online 2022-11-07 11:06

    @eloquence@social.coop

    Open ##5350722

  • @andricheli@mastodon.social 2022-11-07 11:38

    @eloquence@social.coop I completely agree. Mastodon has the extraordinary potential to right the wrongs of social media. I’ve followed Mastodon for years but now it finally has the critical mass needed to make it good. For now, I’m encouraging people to set up a Mastodon account but stay on Twitter, change their name to their mastodon handle, and encourage others to come on over.

    Open ##5350723

  • @eloquence@social.coop im glad i havea profile on here im so cool blowing my own trumpet in thew matrix

    Open ##5350726

  • @JebKFan@mas.to 2022-11-07 12:04

    @eloquence@social.coop Going non-profit and removing pro big companies bias is good. But the Fediverse will need to figure out a way to counter conspiracy theories and defend science - something that big tech wasn't necessarily the worst at.

    Open ##5350728

  • @diogosnows@mastodon.world 2022-11-07 12:20

    @eloquence@social.coop genuine question (new here) how does Mastodon improve on existing offerings, from a social perspective (not just the openness of the protocol). What would prevent a deliberate misinformation (or noise) attack?

    Open ##5350742

  • @WarYarnSpinner@mas.to 2022-11-07 12:38

    @eloquence@social.coop What happens to a user @[server-X] when [server-X] shuts down as you warn might occur?

    Open ##5350747

  • @GivMeCoffee@mastodon.coffee 2022-11-07 12:53

    @eloquence@social.coop wish we could do Facebook next!

    Open ##5350748

  • @eloquence@social.coop I would be hesitant to say this is a Twitter in breakdown for platform to have hundreds of millions users. Musk could be seeing only a drop in the ocean of accounts being deactivated. Right now it’s only the economical side of turning it into a profitable business that’s the facing crisis for Musk with refurbishment of Twitter blue. But for Musk it will be the focus on attracting people back from Gettr and Parler

    Open ##5350749

  • @PhotonEmpress@spacey.space 2022-11-07 13:56

    @eloquence@social.coop I’m not sure Twitter is actually collapsing. It’s such a huge beast of a think that more likely it’s just shedding some fat. A lot of people have moved to Mastodon, yes. But how many moved *and* deleted their twitter account? How many dipped their toes in, but 2 weeks from now when it cools off they will go back to the thing they build a habit around. I don’t know the answers, just have questions.

    Open ##5350751

  • @Fluzbug@mastodon.social 2022-11-07 15:36

    @eloquence@social.coop I’m not convinced mastodon will stay non-profit. I’m guessing a Linux like model will pop up. A few for profit entities that charge a fee for a more stable experience and a bunch of non profit hosts. Or maybe xmmp or email might be a better example. Open protocols but the cost of doing it right requires some funding, and dominant commercial players emerge.

    Open ##5350755

  • @MrsMouse@social.dsmouse.net 2022-11-07 15:38

    @eloquence@social.coop "disruption".

    Open ##5350757

  • @demonocracy@mastodon.social 2022-11-07 16:21

    @eloquence@social.coop what happens when they find out this place, each server has its own code of conduct and moderation? It will be wild west, even compared to the radical right twitter, that is right now..

    Open ##5350759

  • @Geogger@mastodon.online 2022-11-07 08:43

    @eloquence@social.coop

    Open ##5356309

  • @isomeme@mastodon.sdf.org 2022-11-07 16:25

    @eloquence@social.coop , amen. Also, let us never forget that we had decentralized networked communities before -- Usenet, FidoNet, and so forth -- and lost them through neglect when simpler, more convenient centrally-controlled alternatives became available. We must resolve never to move back into a gilded cage.

    Open ##5356313

  • @tompearce49@mastodon.scot 2022-11-07 17:24

    @eloquence@social.coop - I hope that good comes of it and that enough people survive the initial costs. Mastodon deserves to survive largely in its present form, but I know from the bitter experience of friends how exhausting it can be to moderate even relatively small benign places. These will be times of great optimism but you are right to flag up the pitfalls and dangers.

    Open ##5356314

  • @eloquence@social.coop I left the toxic pit of hell. I am here and will stick around.

    Open ##5356315

  • @benfulton@ecoevo.social 2022-11-07 19:04

    tbh that could all happen and I probably wouldn't notice

    Open ##5356316

  • @helenaclaire@mstdn.social 2022-11-07 22:36

    @eloquence@social.coop Thanks for this! I am so grateful for the crew of people who are working day and night to rapidly scale up the infrastructure to support the #TwitterMigration!! It's not just that the #Fediverse creators have made a "replacement" Twitter. They've made a BETTER social media network. I wish I had found you sooner!

    Open ##5356317

  • @heikospecht@muenchen.social 2022-11-07 23:15

    @eloquence@social.coop probably there is a good reason to donate your #mastodonadmin

    Open ##5356318

  • @gg@writing.exchange 2022-11-08 01:36

    @eloquence@social.coop well, doomsday talk didn’t take long did it? Why don’t you picture it turning out differently? Just for fun.

    Open ##5356319

  • @eloquence@social.coop I was talking with friends a few months ago about DAO’s and a decentralized social network. Glad to have found this place. I am super intrigued with Mastodon and will likely be a continual user.

    Open ##5356320

  • @thom_boivin@mastodon.online 2022-11-08 02:22

    @eloquence@social.coop As one of the new refugees from Twitter and Facebook, let me just say right now to please bear with us noobs. Sorry for the disruption, but Mastodon is one of the few alternatives with enough critical mass and momentum to actually be a workable option. Is there a foundation that we can donate to to support the strengthening of the platform?

    Open ##5356321

  • @RevealingLight@mstdn.social 2022-11-08 02:23

    @eloquence@social.coop this is the inspiration for being here, that #musk and #zuckerberg and all the data harvesting from our profiles, also have given us. The ability to change what is so wrong when successive governments have failed us. We take that action on ourselves to create another pathway. 👊🏼#Mastodon 👊🏼

    Open ##5356323

  • @danmcdaid@mastodon.online 2022-11-08 03:13

    @eloquence@social.coop it's a lovely thought, I hope it works

    Open ##5356324

  • @juneg@mas.to 2022-11-08 04:35

    @eloquence@social.coop I certainly hope it succeeds. I’ve only been here a few hours and have met some lovely people. And no politics. What a refreshing change.

    Open ##5356325

  • @eloquence@social.coop Thanks for the moderation work, everyone. From what I've seen, the alt-right trolls are out in force trying to dissuade new users from making a home here. Report. Block. Stay strong.

    Open ##5356326

  • @sweetsprocket23@c.im 2022-11-08 06:15

    @eloquence@social.coop I'm here for this!!!

    Open ##5356327

  • @eloquence@social.coop this is very nice but I don't know where the Twitter had any collapse? Could you tell me?

    Open ##5356328

  • @yaqub@mastodon.online 2022-11-08 08:01

    @eloquence@social.coop it still needs a lot of push

    Open ##5356329