Elektrine lite

← Feed

@david_chisnall@infosec.exchange

2026-08-11 12:10 UTC

@arcanechat@fosstodon.org it is not, any government can block Signal's servers and SMS codes for login in, in places like Iran while Signal is not working during shutdown, ArcaneChat and similar do Iran is completely cut off from the Internet, everything requiring an outside connection is down (unless it was restored recently). If you have a server for AcaneChat inside the country, the Iranian security services do have complete visibility into dataflow (they also ran quite a lot of Tor exit nodes for the same purpose). So if that's the use case you're recommending then you'd better be really confident that you're resilient against passive adversaries or you will get people killed. the thing is, besides any technical matter, it is just plain bad to support Signal when millions of dollars donated go to Amazon and other big tech Okay, finally a point I agree with. But 'Using Signal sends money to Amazon' is not the point that you originally made (though it is a good one).

Replies (1)

  • @arcanechat@fosstodon.org 2026-08-11 13:34

    @david_chisnall@infosec.exchange > Okay, finally a point I agree with. you didn't reply to the post about Amazon knowing users' IPs and passively being able to map "who is talking to whom" even without Signal being aware of it what is your opinion on that? anyways, ultimately it depends on the thread model, and most of the time Signal is not worth the disadvantages or plainly fail to work/solve anyone's problems in practice ex. during censorship situations or autonomy / off-grid

    Open ##4612849