Elektrine lite

← Feed

@mnl@hachyderm.io

2026-09-03 17:06 UTC

@tao@mathstodon.xyz I think there are a lot of parallels to computer science, where one could consider the “daily bread programming”, ie “let’s hack our way through something that’s a reasonable enough solution to the problem” the equivalent of using computer assistance to get to the goal without using the occasion to discover and understand more fundamental principles. But, CS as a field that doesn’t try to directly solve say, a logistics backend for a small business (an incredibly rich problem that can barely be formalized), but can be used as guidance and feedback mechanism to work on more fundamental principles of computing. Or, the same way the steam engine predated thermodynamics as a field of study, llm created solutions could serve as guidance for the actual goal of creating/discovering human understandable descriptions of new structures. Sorry for the rambling, but I’ve very much switched my programming approach to “llm, make the thing I want to make, then figure out some of the fundamental abstraction behind it, and teach me, so that I can express myself more precisely and concisely for my next task”.

Replies (2)

  • @dougmerritt@mathstodon.xyz 2026-09-04 23:06

    @mnl@hachyderm.io You shouldn't be forced to ramble. @tao@mathstodon.xyz

    Open ##5417594

  • @4ad@mathstodon.xyz 2026-09-05 13:58

    @mnl@hachyderm.io The steam engines that predate thermodynamics were useless, and they were useless precisely because their "creators" didn't understand the fundamentals and couldn't predict their behavior. They were, of course, interesting enough objects that people studied them, but the industrial revolution really only started _after_ thermodynamics, in the modern sense, was discovered and understood. This steam engine example, often repeated for whatever reason, is an anti-example. It was precisely deep theoretical understanding that was required in order to productize steam engines, whereas the converse seem to be true of LLMs.

    Open ##5417614