Elektrine lite

← Feed

@antoinechambertloir@mathstodon.xyz

2026-09-10 08:58 UTC

#Math #AI 6/n This is slightly off topic here, but I wish to make a digression and mention that mathematicians also discovered with quite a surprise that not everything can be proved: there are seemingly natural mathematical statements (the one which are well specified, without any ambiguity in them) about which one cannot conclude if one only follows the strict reasoning rules that I evoked. This has the interesting philosophical conclusion that many of our mathematical objects, those given by inambiguous specifications as requested above, are in fact not as well specified as we wished. This has the humble consequence that Hilbert's motto about mathematical quest, We must know, we will know (Wir müssen wissen, wir werden wissen), is in part hopeless. https://youtu.be/wuLFqgx2Pec

Replies (1)

  • #Math #AI 7/n Let us go swiftly to modern times and to modern mathematics. As all scientific fields, it is organized along certain rules, the kind of rules that sociology of science could detail, and also explain their utility and their problems. First there is a multi-faceted compartmentalization of the mathematical activity: - it mostly takes place in research departments of universities, but there are also research departments in private companies (especially for applied research), as well as public places where fundamental research is done (Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, or the Chinese Academy of sciences, etc.) - the activity is separated along broad research themes (my department has a handful of large teams, each of them could be split into 3 or 4 smaller if needed), which has the consequence that few people have a deep understanding of what happens in the offices next to them. - the field is driven by several lighthouses, whatever their actual scientific relevance is: In 1900, Hilbert had proposed 23 problems, in 2000 the Clay foundation proposed 10 other problems, each area of mathematics has a small list of questions which are thought of as particularly important (and for which mathematicians often use the word conjecture).

    Open ##5153656