2023-09-11 10:02 UTC
2/4
Say we have a/b+c. Pre-1917 this was (apparently) interpreted as a/(b+c), and then in 1917 it was changed to mean (a/b)+c. The latter is certainly what we use now.
Some claim this means that 8/2(2+2) is now equal to 16. No, it doesn't mean that at all! 8/2*(2+2) is equal to 16, and pre-1917 was equal to 1, but 8/2(2+2) only has 1 term in the denominator anyway(!), so IS AND ALWAYS WAS equal to 1! i.e. these people are not understanding Terms - 2*(2+2) is 2 terms, but 2(2+2) is 1 term...
Replies (1)
-
@SmartmanApps@dotnet.social 2023-09-11 10:06
3/4 Again, I have found no reference to support that alleged rule change happened, but I DID find the opposite was proposed! On page 313 of Cajori's 1928 "A history of mathematical notations" https://ia600306.us.archive.org/6/items/historyofmathema031756mbp/historyofmathema031756mbp.pdf he says that Stokes PROPOSED that /b+c be interpreted as /(b+c). He says nothing further about it, however it's certainly not the way we interpret it now, so it came to nothing in the end, regardless of what may have initially happened at the time...