2026-04-14 16:50 UTC
@michaelgemar @TerryHancock @futurebird
@michaelgemar @TerryHancock @futurebird
A quibble on "outer darkness" -- in many places (all that I know of), that's inside a parable, where it's literally people getting chucked out into the cold outside of a house at night because they did something wrong in the story. (like the parable of the wedding banquet.)
As to Jewish precursors, Wikipedia here is again useful. Prior texts on "gehinnom" involve flame, punishment, suffering, and estrangement from the divine. The article makes it clear that a lot of scholars see those as metaphorical. I'd argue that it's not really clear Jesus' words (as per the gospels) aren't similarly possibly metaphorical.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hell#Judaism
I think this is one of those cases where there's millennia of so much interpretive reading around these that we automatically map the hegemonic meaning onto simple words that may not clearly carry them. Is that meaning only "straightforward" just because it's so familiar?
Replies (1)
-
@michaelgemar@cosocial.ca 2026-04-14 17:20
@MichaelTBacon @TerryHancock @futurebird I'm by no means a scholar on these issues, but my understanding is that the notion of gehinnom as a place of punishment comes from later rabbinic Judaism, and not from Jewish thought that would have been present in Jesus' time. But yeah, it's all mushed up with a lot of later interpretive work, and what Jesus is reputed to have said is somewhat ambiguous (even putting aside if an historical figure called "Jesus" said anything like what is alleged).