@anschmidtlebuhn@scholar.social
2024-09-30 23:32 UTC
Replies (1)
-
@abucci@buc.ci 2024-10-01 14:55
@anschmidtlebuhn@scholar.social @adityakhanna@mathstodon.xyz @timnitGebru@dair-community.social Reiterating that this isn't about critiquing people but rather ideas, your hypothetical neglects that person A is promoting a known bad concept--a concept that has been deployed to known bad ends before person A took it up--and that person A was well positioned to know that. I gave you two pieces of evidence that the very concept of "genius" has the accepted stature in everyday speech it does today because of the activity of eugenicists. The Stanford-Binet IQ test was developed by and for eugenicists (Lewis Terman). The Genetic Study of Genius was started by a eugenicist (Terman again), for eugenic ends, at Stanford University, which was founded by a robber baron (Leland Stanford) who recruited the university's eugenicist first president (David Starr Jordan). Spend some time honestly digging through the history of the use of that word in the US. It's hard to find a usage that doesn't spring from eugenics. I'm happy to read anything you find. That shouldn't be a surprise. Semantically, the word "genius" almost always connotes that some people are better than other people for some intrinsic reason. That's a way of thinking that meshes quite well with eugenics, besides being problematic on its own. If we weren't suggesting an intrinsic superiority, we'd use words like "educated", "practiced", "highly-trained", and so on that focus on the person's agency and how they came to be able to do whatever it is that impresses us. As has already been said many times, "intelligence" is not like height or mass. It can't be fractioned away from the person exhibiting it. There's no reference IQ point sitting at NIST that you can put on your IQ balance to measure a person's mind. It's a disposition woven right through the whole person and their history. Ignoring and obscuring that reality has been part of the eugenics project for a long time, and we'd do well to acknowledge this. This is the water we swim in here in the US so maybe it's been transparent to you up to this point but I'd strongly encourage taking a closer look at it. You could do worse than starting with Rina Bliss’s book Rethinking Intelligence especially if you're of the mind that intelligence is largely a genetic inheritance (it's not). The Stanford Eugenics History Project, https://www.stanfordeugenics.com , does not mince words. Malcolm Harris's book Palo Alto: A History of California, Capitalism, and the World goes into the eugenicist origins of Stanford University. Last but absolutely not least, Timnit Gebru, who originated this thread, has been outspoken on this (and many other relevant) subjects especially the eugenicist thinking behind some of the ideas coming out of the Silicon Valley tech sector these days. This article by Aubrey Clayton How Eugenics Shaped Statistics, https://nautil.us/how-eugenics-shaped-statistics-238014/ , was eye-opening for me. It specifically calls out Galton (regression and correlation), Fisher (of Fisher information) and Pearson (of the Pearson correlation coefficient). "Regression to the mean"--Galton's idea--arose from eugenic thinking: it was invented in an attempt to explain, among other things, how "highly intelligent" parents could have "less intelligent" children, given the eugenic premise that intelligence was hereditary and so-called excellent stock should always produce excellent offspring. The obvious explanation is that intelligence is not measurable or heritable like that, but eugenicists do not accept this. Nobody's arguing we shouldn't use statistics anymore just because bad people bent it towards their questionable ends. Nobody's saying that you're a eugenicist if you do a linear regression in python. Those are strawmen positions. Rather, I think it is wise--and a requirement of good scholarship and careful thought--to skeptically examine the influence of eugenics and acknowledge where it's reared its head, especially given the stakes. Who benefits from ignoring these associations or asserting, without evidence, that they don't or shouldn't matter? I think the assessment of statements like "X is a genius at math" becomes significantly more nuanced after all this. It's decidedly not an innocent statement, even if the person saying it isn't aware of why and therefore can't reasonably be called culpable. As for people who do know or could know / did know or could have known, well... And with that I'm done. mic drop.