2026-10-17 09:23 UTC
Actually let me analyze again your comment here: I thought you were right at first but thinking about it not really.
First let me address : I didn’t know about RIAA, this kind of paternalistic way of addressing people is not good in any way. We aren’t all USA-centric (like you?).
Then about the “steal” argument:
it is a vocabulary used for century by Marxist organizations about the value taken by the bourgeoisie from the proletariat work.
the argument of “copying is OK” is missing the point : any FOSS dev/organization I know would gladly give their work to you, individual. But not to big tech to commercialize it and make extreme amount of money, as well as steering conversation towards fascism in the process. While also having an amazingly big impact on the environment.
“both have it afterwards” : any work done on computer can be seen like this but this is such a falacy : if your an accountant and you boss copy your accounting sheets and do not pay you, it is not stealing? You both have the file, for you it won’t make you any money, he will. Big tech taking FOSS code for their profit is not piracy as of individual accessing cultural product they cannot afford in the first place. And if you make profit from piracy this is a whole other discussion I would gladly here your thoughts about it.
Replies (2)
-
@m532@lemmy.ml 2026-10-17 12:24
Private property is theft. “Intellectual property” is a form of private property. It exclusively benefits the bourgeois. Regarding your third bullet point: Try your example again, but this time the boss doesn’t copy the file. It’s still labor theft. The copying is irrelevant.
-
@AlteredEgo@lemmy.ml 2026-10-18 13:16
Downloading this comment is not authorized. Then about the “steal” argument: You wouldn’t download an argument, would you? Or would you? What, you’re reading this in your browser without authorization from me?? FBI, open up!!!