2026-11-07 14:09 UTC
Replies (3)
-
@Daxter101@lemmy.blahaj.zone 2026-11-07 15:50
I agree with the sentiment, and given the big picture of what you advocate for, Every single trans person on this planet deserves to have their right to access recognized, codified, and enforced. within the current working system of health, you have my full agreement and support. The reason, I think, that this post grates you a bit, is because behind it, there is a secondary ideological belief. That is, a different view around enforcement, the anarchic one. The idea (that I as a trans person agree with) is, the state, the entity which decides legal limitations around medications, shouldn’t even be allowed to have the ability to manage HRT, because if it has the ability, it will unavoidably use it at some point down the line. Unless you’re willing to say that drugs like nicotine shouldn’t be over the counter due to the real health risk they pose, then it isn’t the state legislators’ job, to decide via restriction, who gets access to HRT medication. The idea around prescription drugs, is that you’re supposed to have easy access to them whenever you need them via doctor’s orders, and they are restricted for one of these three reasons: Either 1. They are useless outside their use AND rapidly irreversibly dangerous, 2. They can be made into threats for the state (see, bomb materials), or 3. Their risk is so great, that there’s value protecting people from seeking them, see, opioids and other addictive substances. HRT isn’t addictive, and is slow acting, while being life saving for people who often are failed by the current social system. The only reason to limit HRT, in a world where Alcohol is in super markets for 2 euro per liter, is reason number 2., every 50 years that fascists come around. This is one of those many, many cases, where, your beautiful and correct dream of safety for our world that I agree with, should maybe*(/s)* not start from restrictions to minorities.
-
@carin_heron@lemmy.blahaj.zone 2026-11-07 16:02
So, I understand the points you’re making about medication regulation. Certainly, ibuprofen carries enough risk with abuse for the ease of access to be questioned, for example, but I’m unsure of the claim here that there are other ways for open access to HRT. It seems that the conclusion here is that a liberal civil rights campaigns are more effective with less risk, but I’m sure if that’s the point, since, y’know, that would require trans people to even further risk their safety by cooperating with institutions that are largely dedicated to the genocide of trans people. I’m sure that would carry a less general medical risk since, of course, it is not only trans people making use of these medications, but I don’t see how this could be argued as more dangerous for trans people specifically. I think it’s also crucial to note here that even the non-violent actions that are necessary to fight for that protection carries the risk of incarceration, and therefore, significantly high chances of sexual violence given the disproportionate rate that trans people experience sexual violence in those cases. Even more, in the US, there are many cases where we’d be asking trans people to risk forceful “detransition” to participate in said campaign, as that is an accepted policy within the US carceral institution. I do hope I’m misreading the last part of your comment for that reason, as I think that kind of point would ask us to ignore the trans people who died to secure what access we do have (very many of which suffered the consequences I listed above), as well as the reality that these institutions only conceded rights to that access as part of a longer campaign against transness, the consequences of which we are witnessing through the current wave of genocidal policies targetting trans people. With all that in mind, I find it difficult to weigh the valid concerns over medical safety and the specific needs for some of the most vulnerable people in our society. Surely, there is an acceptable risk I’m willing to generalize should that mean fewer trans youth die because they refuse to live without access to themselves.
-
@Cethin@lemmy.zip 2026-11-08 06:29
Driving a car comes with much more risk than many medications that are prescription-only. If we provide everyone healthcare and free doctors visits then fine, we can be more restrictive with prescriptions. Until then many people can’t afford to go to the doctor to be prescribed something. Yes, there are risks, but we take risks every day. People should be allowed to decide for themselves what risks they are willing to take, not the government. The government putting things behind large paywalls is them restricting what you can do with your own body.