Elektrine lite

← Feed

@wonderingwanderer@sopuli.xyz

2026-11-06 00:10 UTC

That’s interesting, I didn’t know that about the Canadian Senate. Honestly though, and this is something I’ve been thinking about a lot lately, the bicameral legislative system in general is a vestige of old social stratification from a bygone age. The lower chamber (in the US that’s the House of Representatives, but in Canada I suppose it’s the House of Parliament) is basically a derivative of the House of Commons from England/UK. I think it was established by the Magna Carta (if I remember correctly) to give commoners (peasants) a say in government. The upper chamber, being the Senate, in a similar way derives conceptually from the English House of Lords. In other words, from its inception, the Senate as a concept was always intended to be the house representing the nation’s aristocracy. Things have changed over time of course, but there are still echos of its origins in the way it functions as the upper chamber, and also in the way people are selected as Senators versus as Representatives. I’m not saying we should immediately abolish the bicameral system. There are certainly still good reasons to keep both chambers in place (and honestly we could potentially even eventually expand it to a tricameral or quadracameral system, adding a chamber that represents different career fields, or one that that represents different academic disciplines). But it’s just something to be aware of about the history of senates in general.

Replies (1)

  • @ininewcrow@lemmy.ca 2026-11-06 01:52

    One thing I think every modern government should employ is a way or means to either change, upgrade or renew a nations constitution or overall governing laws. To change it or update it every 100 hundred years - or every 50 years or after every 10 elections or something. Basically to enshrine into law that the whole system has to be updated to modern standards every few generations to keep up with changing times … a constitution or set of laws that are allowed to change or evolve over time. I know that the current system tries to employ change over time … but all those changes are based on the laws, system and regulations of a bygone era … systems like ‘senates’ in Canada … or the electoral college in the US Existing or old laws and regulations were meant to deal with problems or issues from a hundred or even 200 years ago but usually those problems are no longer applicable centuries later … and those insitutionalized changes are only abused to manipulate the democratic system. Updating and upgrading the system every hundred years would serve to evolve the system over time and prevent forces from abusing existing regulations that no longer function. I am sure that any new system that would be developed would have its own abuses but at least everyone would have an opportunity to do something about it all rather than just sit still and maintain the status quo, even if it means a degraded democratic system. No matter the country … every nation should have a way to update its system to better represent people in its current age. How do we expect to represent the modern American or Canadian governments using regulations from 100 - 200 years ago when everyone lived with horse and buggy and didn’t have world wide mass communication? And in the future, how do we except future generations to deal with their problems 200 years from now using regulations from the 1900s? Human society and civilization is in constant change and evolution and technology … we can’t expect our governing systems to stay static over generations while everything changes.

    Open ##5538526