Elektrine lite

← Feed

@kevin@fedi.kbg.sh

2026-10-23 21:19 UTC

@glocq@mathstodon.xyz I don’t care if something is nominally open source. I care about my ability to port, maintain, and run it myself. TeX asks almost nothing of the OS and is written in a very simple dialect of Pascal. I’ve written my own compiler. Typst requires a multi million line of code compiler and very specific computing environment.

Replies (3)

  • @glocq@mathstodon.xyz 2026-10-23 21:55

    @kevin@fedi.kbg.sh Ok I think I understand your point. I understand that being "nominally open source" isn't the be all end all of software, but IMO your initial criticism lacked specifics to the point of being misleading. From what I understand, all your concerns are related to Typst being written in Rust. I don't think I'm alone in not immediately identifying the Rust compiler as a potentially problematic dependency (with how standard it's become). It would have helped being more specific.

    Open ##5387745

  • @crazazy@tiny.tilde.website 2026-10-23 22:13

    @kevin@fedi.kbg.sh @glocq@mathstodon.xyz could you elaborate on the "specific computing environment" here? From the readme it seems that what you need to tweak it is mostly just the rust compiler + cargo, which most computers should be capable of working with. Compared to having to rely on overleaf or texlive to deal with document templates I was given for my bachelor's thesis I don't see typst being much worse in that regard?

    Open ##5387747

  • @muvlon@hachyderm.io 2026-10-24 10:39

    @kevin@fedi.kbg.sh @glocq@mathstodon.xyz It's written in an ad-hoc dialect of Pascal so obscure that most TeX distributions don't even use that source code and instead rely on a pretty unreadable C translation.

    Open ##5387748