Elektrine lite

← Feed

@Diva@lemmy.ml

2026-10-24 18:12 UTC

‘at least they won’t lock us up’ is a selective reading of history. liberals have done exactly that if threatened. the liberal state locked people up for being black and being too critical of the regime before trump. it was democrats that were raiding gay bars and opposing gay rights until the movement got big enough that they rebranded and wrapped themselves in the flag. the ‘best environment to work in’ assumption only holds if the goal is incremental reform within the system rather than replacing it, which goes back to the core disagreement. a system that presents the best environment for working toward its own replacement is a contradiction in terms. it presents that environment precisely until you get close enough to actually threaten it. also all of the things you credit the social liberals for were concessions extracted by organized labor through strike, occupations and political pressure that the liberals were actively resisting until they had no choice. crediting liberalism for them is like crediting the landlord for not raising rent after a rent strike.

Replies (1)

  • @luciferofastora@feddit.org 2026-10-25 07:53

    Okay, we’re definitely working with different definitions then. I don’t see much of a point arguing about the history of the term and associated policies. Today’s liberals are certainly better than conservatives or fascists when it comes to human rights and shit, and that’s the people we’re working with right now. We can labour over the sins of their ancestors, or we can attempt to influence their policies to our benefit until we’re in a position where we no longer need their cooperation. a system that presents the best environment for working toward its own replacement is a contradiction in terms. Counterpoint: wouldn’t a system that doesn’t even permit these conversations be a worse environment? If there are worse environments, doesn’t that make the others better by comparison? Isn’t the “least bad” equivalent to “the best”? Alternatively, what would you posit as the best conditions for working towards toppling the system?

    Open ##5433375