Elektrine lite

← Feed

@rastilin@aus.social

2023-08-08 07:26 UTC

@TaliaRinger@mathstodon.xyz I think people can only hate on Oppenheimer with the luxury of both hindsight and victory. At the time both the Germans and Japanese were carrying out horrific atrocities while taking more and more territory and the Germans had their own nuclear program. In the end the Allies won and the bomb only got used very late in the war; but none of the scientists working on it knew that this would be the case. I also think the media is tilted to give this kind of reaction. If the movie started with 30 minutes of Japanese and German atrocities and them talking about how they're going to take over America the movie would hit very differently.

Replies (1)

  • @TaliaRinger@mathstodon.xyz 2023-08-09 04:30

    @rastilin@aus.social Yeah, so one reason it was very easy to relate to Oppenheimer is that I am also a Jew, and my grandparents are Holocaust survivors. My grandfather in particular survived a Nazi death camp, and was orphaned and homeless after the war. I do not think I would be able to even think about tradeoffs when posed with a chance to stop the Nazis. I'd just do it. I feel haunted by that genocide still and I have nightmares about it sometimes. As a kid I was afraid of public showers because I thought I'd get gassed. I am emphatically not a pacifist when genocide is happening, and I believe that the Russian war in Ukraine is an ongoing act of genocide. I strongly support intervention, the same way I would strongly support intervention in China for the Uyghur genocide, or intervention in Myanmar for the Rohingya genocide. The larger picture is that something that starts as an act of intervention in genocide can easily be used as an act of genocide, or something equally horrifying. I don't think pacifism is the answer, but I do think I need to sit with that and understand what it means for the military-academic complex.

    Open ##2187559