2026-10-16 20:21 UTC
Replies (3)
-
@XiJinpingStanAccount@lemmy.ml 2026-10-16 20:58
So here’s how I see it: There is a big difference between “AI generated” code and “AI assisted” code. Or just anything. To put it in terms most people can more understand let’s say you were writing a book. If you have an LLM generate the book its gonna suck and be slop. But if you write the rough draft, then paste it into an LLM and say, “Look through this and find typos and other mistakes and point them out to me”. Then you go and check the things it finds and fix them yourself, that is fine. It’s just a really good spellcheck at that point. Even if you say “suggest a fix” it’s fine. For coding you could even tell it like “Take this line of code and suggest 5 different ways to do the same thing that might work better” then test them all out and see which one you like best. I have personally used an LLM to help clean up my dotfiles for example. I don’t want to read through all that shit and find the old junk I need to remove or change. So I just throw them at an LLM and have it point things out to me. Or say you know you have a file but don’t know the exact filename. Go into the folder its in and dump the output of ls into an LLM. Tell it what file you need vaguely. Have it read them and give you the correct filename. Then check it yourself. The problem comes from people who just generate stuff and don’t do the work of double checking it themselves.
-
@Ek-Hou-Van-Braai@piefed.social 2026-10-16 21:04
One thing people forget is that many human coders absolutely suck at what they do and or don’t care. 80% code I’ve seen at clients is shit, some if it is hilariously bad, like absolute dog shit. I’ve had a meeting where I had to explain the codebase to a new joiner, we were crying laughing at how bad the code was. This particular fortune 500 company never cared to fix it, they just wanted more features. So yes AI can be shit, but god I trust it more than some of the shit I’ve seen humans write. Shit devs will make shit code with or without AI. Good devs will make good code, just faster with AI
-
@Not_mikey@lemmy.dbzer0.com 2026-10-17 00:03
My understanding is that AI/LLMs can generate code that works, but often that code is more bloated/convoluted than code written by a decent coder, making it less efficient and more difficult to maintain. This was more true last year but developments in both the frontier models and the harnesses used to control and direct those models have gotten better to the point where I’d say the code is better then most devs. People on here don’t want to admit it but if you did a “coding turing test” between Claude and some random dev coding by hand I’d bet most of the time a dev would say the AI output is better.