2026-10-17 01:55 UTC
I’m kind of gobsmacked by this. I’ve heard younger developers compare LLM with compiler and chalked it up to ignorance, but I don’t get what this is.
Can I write code in assembly? Yes. Of course. It’s true that I never do it, but if there was a rule that you needed to write some assembly now and then to certify as a kernel developer I don’t see how it would be any kind of impediment.
Comparing more directly: if you hand me a compiled binary and the source code and ask “why is the bit at address 0xXXXXXXXXX a 0?” I can, with 100% certainty, answer that. Probably in less than a day of effort. If I ask "why did the LLM output “for” as the XXXXth word of its utterance, can Linus say why?
And “can you write a good commit message without an editor?” Uhhh? At least when I was in school, this was something people did for fun/messing around. I still do cat > somefile when I need to put some quick text together. In fact, Claude will sometimes write a Git commit by cat-ing into a file–which it’s doing because there’s so many online examples of this. Fucking weird things for Linus to pick. Makes me think his brain’s rotted.
Replies (2)
-
@Tattorack@lemmy.world 2026-10-17 03:13
There was another article posted on Lemmy somewhere where recently other kernel developers had to clean up after Torvalds as of recent. So yeah. I’d say his brain has rotted.
-
@hirihit640@sh.itjust.works 2026-10-17 07:16
If I ask "why did the LLM output “for” as the XXXXth word of its utterance, can Linus say why? If you have the model that was used, and the seed used for the generation, then yes you can trace the weights and figure out how everything was generated. AI is deterministic. And compilers can be just as “nondeterministic” if you don’t know what compiler was used and what flags were enabled.