2026-09-20 03:55 UTC
@corbden@defcon.social
it would have been really hard to put bombadil in the movies. i love bombadil in the books but i don't mind his exclusion from the movies. it was such a tonal shift and side quest type situation
i always viewed bombadil as a self-insert by tolkien
as if the hobbits had suddenly broken the fourth wall (wait... that's with the audience, what's the "fourth wall" with the author?) and had a nice diversion sitting around with the guy who wrote them
Replies (2)
-
@cy@fedicy.us.to 2026-09-20 05:14
They did him really well in The Rings of Power.
-
@ryanprior@mastodon.social 2026-09-20 05:14
@benroyce@mastodon.social @corbden@defcon.social I think it was cowardice to omit him. Yes it's a tonal shift, which is all the more meaningful where reality itself was sung into existence and music is magical. But instead of interrogating what that means and bringing it to the screen, they elided it.