@thethunderwolf@lemmy.dbzer0.com
2026-11-15 02:33 UTC
Replies (3)
-
@NotAnOtter@lemmus.org 2026-11-15 04:40
From what I’m gathering from other comments it mostly seems to be a term that intentionally agitates people. People hear it and think chromosomes. Other people say it and mean hormones. Apparently some view “Biologically women” as a hate term. The term doesn’t accomplish anything. Transphobes will disagree on a weaker stance anyways so you don’t need to elevate it. Allies with agree with a better articulated version (i.e. 'transmen on HRT have hormones that match a mans hormones".) But if an ally interprets the statement to claim “There is no biological difference between a man and a women” and disagrees based on chromosomes, then they will be banned from communities for transphobia.
-
@waterwasamistake@lemmy.zip 2026-11-15 11:42
yeah sure but most people aren’t scientists or trans and i don’t see what value it brings to the discussion. My point is that arguing in favor of trans people needs to be most of all effective. Non science people discussing things where both only have surface level understanding and one party also don’t really WANT to understand the science seems utterly pointless and even harmful to me. Especially bc it isn’t about science it is about emotion for these people. It does not matter AT ALL if trans women are or aren’t biological women, what matters is the agreement that people deserve their human rights and healthcare no matter if i personally don’t agree with how they describe themselves. And thats what the discussions should be as well as the fact that they are just a vulnerable minority that the right uses to stir shit up. I personally don’teven discuss this at all with people it doesn’t matter what someones biology is in any interaction i have with them and basic rules of courtsy says you call people what they want to be called. If i want to keep my freedom i have to accept other people doing things i do not like with their freedom Doctors and their patients should decide what course of action they going to do, nobody else. I support trans rights as human rights but i don’t think trans rights needs to include everyone agreeing on semantics.
-
@SpokeFace654@lemmy.today 2026-11-15 16:30
Should be able to give birth really