Elektrine lite

← Feed

@antoinechambertloir@mathstodon.xyz

2026-09-10 09:20 UTC

#Math #AI 9/n Already several years ago, AI companies have decided to enter the game of mathematics. Their official motivation (I quote from memory one of the Google Deepmind leaders, last year at Leiden) is to provide us with new tools. But sometimes, the word escapes them that they wish to simply “solve mathematics”. It should be made clear that in no way can anybody “solve mathematics”. What is possible is solving a given mathematical question, or more likely, proving something related to a given mathematical question that the mathematical community views as an advance towards that question. Once a problem is solved, new problems emerge, either because the earlier question now makes it possible to set, or because we naturally turn our eyes to something else. Mostly, solving a question indicates that some mathematical tools are powerful and we wish to try those tools on questions that we feel could be addressed with them. What is also possible is “disrupting mathematics” by disrupting the fragile equilibrium of the field, as a sociological construct. But they wouldn't want to do that, would they?

Replies (1)

  • #Math #AI 10/n I will now try to summarize the events of this hot mathematical summer. Mid July, Levent Alpöge, a mathematician trained at Princeton in number theory who is now working for the AI company Anthropic, published a counterexample to the so-called “Jacobian conjecture”. This was a natural question in a field called algebraic geometry that had been put forward in the 1960s by mathematicians such as Zariski and Abhyankar, especially because its statement doesn't require anything more than basic undergraduate algebra. (As it happens very often, earlier traces of this question can be found, back to the end of the 19th century.) We are facing here a basic question, which was clearly an open conjecture in the field, but whose sociological status was unclear. Indeed, very few prominent mathematicians decided to tackle it, while a number of people with less competence devoted a lot of their energy to prove it. We now know that it has been in vain, but even there, one could have doubted the mathematical interest of the question, and one important algebraic geometer said me so in very clear terms around 2012. Indeed, this conjecture asserted that every family $(f_1,..,f_n)$ of $n$ polynomials in $n$ variables with complex coefficients whose Jacobian is a nonzero constant is invertible. (Conversely, it is quite easy to prove that for any such family which is invertible, the Jacobian is a nonzero constant.) What this colleague made me observe is that it is extremely unlikely that one gets such a family for which we can prove that the Jacobian is a nonzero constant *without* already knowing that it is invertible. So what is this conjecture good for?

    Open ##5153659