Elektrine lite

← Feed

@tao@mathstodon.xyz

2026-09-05 15:19 UTC

A clarification in response to recent rumors about a possible solution to the Navier-Stokes problem: I am not aware of any significant developments in this regard; the above discussion is hypothetical, but not completely implausible at the current level of development of AI technology. The point remains that there is a substantial opportunity cost in converting a historically productive and motivating problem (such as Navier-Stokes regularity) into a mere viral social media post advertising some benchmark progress, rather than actually advancing the field and developing the next generation of both problems to ask, and people to work on them.

Replies (7)

  • @wxd@fairy.id 2026-09-05 16:27

    @tao@mathstodon.xyz I have a more radical idea。Maybe we don't need humans behind math。Soon, artificial intelligence will develop branches of mathematics that humans can't understand.We just need to test its correctness in the real world.Soon, of course, we're going to be talking about more than just math, and that's going to extend to our world.In my opinion, this is not like a technological revolution, but like a biological revolution.From prokaryote to eukaryote, from plant to animal.Mathematics is not only human, but also verifiable.

    Open ##5417582

  • @tao@mathstodon.xyz It's too bad that there isn't a lot of money or prestige in training or running models to explain and describe math. If tomorrow ChatGPT announced an unreadable but formally verified proof of Navier-Stokes, that would be a disaster. But if tomorrow ChatGPT became capable of teaching us how to solve Navier-Stokes, that might be interesting.

    Open ##5417583

  • @solrize@mathstodon.xyz 2026-09-06 00:32

    @tao@mathstodon.xyz @davidlowryduda@mathstodon.xyz Aha I hadn't heard anything recent about NS but had heard some months ago that DeepMind was working on it, and I wondered if @tao@mathstodon.xyz might be involved. I had imagined a much more complicated version of @tao@mathstodon.xyz's 2014 result about the averaged 3D equation, using AI to blast through the fog of calculation and find a blowup in NS. Yes of course I'd rather see humans solve the problem but I can imagine it being intractably messy.

    Open ##5417584

  • @richh@cupoftea.social 2026-09-06 08:46

    @tao@mathstodon.xyz Most of this is over my head and I don’t know what ansatz means(!), but is a reasonable TLDR/summary that PA (probabilistic automation) in pure maths can be considered analogous to the “negative result problem” in pharma (and academic publishing broadly) where neg results are discarded or not reported even though they may have value in respect of other problems, or at least “here’s why method 1027 doesn’t work”? In the case, because nobody actually does any thinking about to understand *why* it doesn’t work. This would be very ironic considering a touted use-case for PA is to trawl pharma datasets for compounds that were passed over as unsuitable for the target application but which might have another use that we not identified at the time. Of course, pharma research is more about concrete results, whereas pure math is more about broader thinking, and failed approaches can profoundly inform seemingly-unrelated fields.

    Open ##5417585

  • @tao@mathstodon.xyz Thank you for these posts. Which papers do you recommend regarding the connections with symplectic topology and your contribution "Finite time blowup for an averaged three dimensional Navier-Stokes equations"? I have a naive question as well : Why can't we say the results of J. Chen and T. Hou in the axissymmetric case of 3D incompressible Euler equations, considered in the regime where the dissipation is negligible, provide an answer to the global regularity problem?

    Open ##5417587

  • @y1ngst3r@mathstodon.xyz 2026-09-09 08:59

    @tao@mathstodon.xyz I see what you mean about AI brute-forced solutions contaminating the endeavor. But couldn't mathematicians just choose to ignore the AI solution and continue working towards an independent proof, noting insights discovered along the way as usual? Aside from losing the satisfaction of solving a problem for the first time ever, wouldn't the first human solver still be able to produce the same impact?

    Open ##5417588

  • @rjf_berger@mathstodon.xyz 2026-09-09 13:21

    @tao@mathstodon.xyz Some thought on the recent advance assuming the result holds: perhaps singularities are mathematics exposing the artificiality of treating matter as an infinitely divisible continuum. A nonlinear continuum theory can imply some "UV divergence" - it can drive structure to ever smaller scales, (𝑘→∞ ), and potentially to divergent gradients/velocities in finite time. Real matter instead eventually leaves the hydrodynamic description and becomes molecular/quantum. While this wouldn't prove atomism, a fundamental continuum theory could have other types of short-distance regularizations, but it seems tempting to me to interpret finite-time blow-up as the continuum model dynamically discovering its own missing microscopic cutoff.

    Open ##5417589