Elektrine lite

← Feed

@YosemiteGromit@lemmygrad.ml

2026-11-08 22:11 UTC

Dengists be like… If Stalin was against Bukharin he would’ve been against Deng. I see too many people glazing red social democracy. The DTOB is wearing the skin of the DTOP and people are falling for it.

Replies (6)

  • @gualudengren@lemmy.ml 2026-11-08 22:19

    I truly do understand that reading, and more importantly understanding and applying theory is a truly monumental task however you really should attempt it sometime.

    Open ##5504338

  • @gary_host_laptop@lemmy.ml 2026-11-08 22:31

    you lack understanding of dialectical materialism and are thinking in eternal absolutes. marxists don’t oppose or support any one thing in particular as inherently evil or counter revolutionary. and in the context of deng it certainly should be supported. you cannot know what stalin would have thought, and even if he did does not mean he was right, for all the good things he did there is always the chance of error. the ussr fell, but china is still standing and upholding tens of millions of working class people. The proportion of planning to market forces is not the essential difference between socialism and capitalism. A planned economy is not equivalent to socialism, because there is planning under capitalism too; a market economy is not capitalism, because there are markets under socialism too. Planning and market forces are both means of controlling economic activity. The essence of socialism is liberation and development of the productive forces, elimination of exploitation and polarization, and the ultimate achievement of prosperity for all. This concept must be made clear to the people. Are securities and the stock market good or bad? Do they entail any dangers? Are they peculiar to capitalism? Can socialism make use of them? We allow people to reserve their judgement, but we must try these things out. If, after one or two years of experimentation, they prove feasible, we can expand them. Otherwise, we can put a stop to them and be done with it. We can stop them all at once or gradually, totally or partially. What is there to be afraid of? So long as we keep this attitude, everything will be all right, and we shall not make any major mistakes. In short, if we want socialism to achieve superiority over capitalism, we should not hesitate to draw on the achievements of all cultures and to learn from other countries, including the developed capitalist countries, all advanced methods of operation and techniques of management that reflect the laws governing modern socialized production. — Deng Xiaoping, 1992, Excerpts from Talks Given in Wuchang, Shenzhen, Zhuhai and Shanghai. To attempt to answer yes or no to the question whether any particular means of struggle should be used, without making a detailed examination of the concrete situation of the given movement at the given stage of its development, means completely to abandon the Marxist position. — V.I. Lenin, Guerrilla Warfare (1906)

    Open ##5504385

  • @woodenghost@hexbear.net 2026-11-08 23:51

    I know all the arguments that the comments in here will reply to OP already and mostly agree. Of course building socialism is a long process. Of course there’s dialectics. But I would like to see more nuance in the daily reporting. We all support the war of Iran and the axis of resistance against US imperialism, right? But no war ever goes smoothly. If there is a setback or a heavy blow dealt by the enemy, we don’t sugar coat it. We discuss it, analyze the implications. Similarly, we should support China. But if we accept, that China is socialist, not yet communist, then that means by definition, that the class war within China is still going on. Just as it continued in the Soviet Union after the revolution and was ultimately lost from within (under pressure, of course, but still). So inevitably, I wonder, how is the class war inside China going? We hear about the many positive achievements every day. But is it all one glorious victory after another? Not one little setback? No partial retreat ever? Only one brilliant strategic master strok after another? What’s the most contested front? In 2020, there were about double the number of billionaires in China compared to today (over 1000, at one point). Apparently it got so bad, that decisive action became necessary. What prevent earlier action? Then, after the crackdowns, this number dropped to about 400. Just since last year alone, the number has risen again by about 20% to over 500 again. Isn’t that a little setback? How did it happen? Will the number continue to rise? They have limited power now, but I’m sure they strive for more. If China is socialist, there must be struggle, there must be classes, there must be enemies of the proletariat within China. Who exactly are our enemies inside China? How do they fight? I want names. Not vague gestures towards theory. As in the Soviet Union, there must be revisionist and anti-revisionist streams in the party. Who’s got the upper hand at what time and on what issue? These questions are never discussed. Instead, people pretend China is just one unified block. That’s racist. I want trustworthy news with a Marxist class analysis about the struggle within China or all the purely positive ones will lose credibility. I get, that to the outside, we have to be united in our support due to relentless imperialist anti-China propaganda. But here, amongst ourselves, we can be what we are: materialists.

    Open ##5504638

  • @m532@lemmygrad.ml 2026-11-09 11:32

    Let’s put this through the libspeak to english translator: “China bad”

    Open ##5508865

  • @Saymaz@lemmygrad.ml 2026-11-09 12:05

    How can China be socialist if it has a stock market?

    Open ##5509002

  • @Cowbee@lemmy.ml 2026-11-09 12:25

    What determines if a system is capitalist or socialist is not whether there is any private property at all, but which class controls the commanding heights of the economy and the state. Publicly owned industry in systems dominated by capitalists is not socialism, as it services the continued profit of capitalists and the accumulation of capital, be it through securing imperialism, preventing revolution, etc. Likewise, private ownership under socialism is not capitalism, as in China the marketized sector is the underdeveloped portion of the economy, and is used to take advantage of capital’s ability to stitch together disparate productive forces into what can better be used in planned economy. Marxism is not a moral dogma. Private property outlives its historical utility when it develops to national scale, and at this point it becomes beneficial to fold it into the public sector to expedite development. To fold in underdeveloped and disparate production to the planned economy is to strain the economic system by trying to account for all of the tiny producers. Marxists see the basis of markets as disparate, decentralized production, and the basis of planned economy in large, centralized production. Socialism is not a moral virtue to be implemented by decree, but instead a transitional status where markets are transformed gradually into planned economy as the productive forces develop. The people you decry as “Dentists” are just Marxist-Leninists. Deng Xiaoping did not invent this interpretation of Marx, it originated with Marx and was held by Lenin. The Stalin economy was progressive, and worked very well, but it was not an “ideal” economy from a Marxist perspective, and instead mostly resembled a siege economy. The enormous gains they made despite a siege economy shows how superior socialism is to capitalism, and how enormously flexible it is. The incredible and rapid transformation of China from a semi-feudal backwater to the indisputable world leader today in less than a century is a testement to what socialism in a more traditional sense can accomplish. Please study Marx and Engels. I will never drag Stalin through the mud, nor the Soviet Union, but you are not a materialist with this analysis. At best, you’re a moralist. You need to re-study the basis of scientific socialism and what it actually means to develop the productive forces.

    Open ##5509059