Elektrine lite

← Feed

@southsamurai@sh.itjust.works

2026-11-07 21:39 UTC

Oh, I’m fully on board with DIY as a life saving measure. It infuriates me that anyone, much less a kid, has to go that route, but it is an ugly world full of hate and even just plain bias, so DIY is the only realistic option for way too many people. I’m just saying that trying to make a class of meds OTC isn’t the long term answer to that problem. I’m so sick of seeing good people treated like garbage for the crime of not fitting preconceptions. It’s one of the things that shifted my views on the desirability of violent revolution away from a purely pacifist stance. Too many people get crushed waiting for a peaceful change. But that’s not really on topic, sorry for the mini rant. Coming back to it, I think that trying to reclassify HRT meds as OTC would, at best, kick the can down the road on trans rights to access. At worst, it turns into another fight of its own that just isn’t useful on a strategic level, and since it doesn’t achieve the goal any better than other paths to open access, the risks it brings aren’t worth it.

Replies (1)

  • Oh yes, I didn’t think you were against DIY HRT generally based on your comment. I do think systemic violence is very much on topic, especially following my comment. This is why I’m a bit confused about this final point again, about wider access being definitively less effective and more harmful than alternatives, since we don’t really have alternatives. Every act of cooperation with a liberal-capitalist system is “kicking the can down the road,” since that system fundamentally desires the eradication of queerness. As far as violence goes, I’m not sure how you could argue that, again, an increased generalized risk to the benefit of trans people is in any way more risky than simply continuing the current path, which is civil recognition, when that literally resulted in the current moment of trans genocide and is concurrent with the consistently high rate of self-harm and suicide among trans people. As far as I see it here, your point is that a potential threat to the general population is more of a concern than the very real and immediate threat faced by trans people today. As you’ve stated in other comments, there already is HRT misinformation, and the systemic oppression that we experience has necessitated community responses and education campaigns. So, I don’t really see how this would be a problem for trans people specifically, whom already have an information network via the preexistng ones within the trans community. I also don’t see how this would be any more or less difficult to implement in the current cultural moment within the US (and anglosphere) and/or EU contexts, since, again, we are already dealing with the negative consequences of cooperation in the first place. I’m not sure what strategic value there is in foregoing campaigns that can codify trans access to HRT without explicit trans rights in mind. So, could you please explain what alternatives you’re referring to?

    Open ##5523796