2026-11-14 09:54 UTC
Replies (1)
-
@Supercrunchy@programming.dev 2026-11-14 11:00
Try losing your phone and see how easy is to recover from that, or having to explain to your grandma how they lost their accounts everywhere because they didn’t have a backup strategy for passkeys, even though they remember the password for the account (!). There’s also the very big issue of attestation, where websites can force users to use a specific password manager, which doesn’t allow you to move the key to a fully free solution. This was made for companies to force the users to use real hardware tokens or only approved authenticator apps, but nothing prevents google to start forcing you to use only google authenticator to login to google, or for apple to own an iphone to login to a site. Usually all big-company passwors managers don’t have any way to export the key, and you have to wonder why. This attestation threat is very real: here is somebody that AFAIK was part of the w3c committee that made passkeys threatening to use attestation against keepassxc for allowing the user to export keys: github.com/keepassxreboot/keepassxc/issues/10407 Overall, it feels like yet another complicated technology, that also allows big companies to consolidate power.